Get paid for the questions and custom requests you already get from followers.

Create your free Brillay link

For creators

Art Teachers: Get Paid to Critique Student Artwork and Portfolios

Charge for the critiques students DM you: photo and reference in, ranked fixes and a paint-over back, plus art school portfolio reviews. You set the price.

Updated November 2026

Get paid for this β€” with Brillay

Who spends a free Sunday sorting a senior's 28 camera-roll photos into keep, cut and rework the week of her early deadline? List that review at your price with a delivery time you choose, so November's rush runs on your calendar, not hers.

Brillay is a link in your bio where followers pay you directly for:

Custom WorkPaid QuestionsTipsGoalsPersonalized Videos

A parent fresh from your National Portfolio Day recap taps your bio and pays by card as a guest without leaving Instagram, her daughter's numbered PDF attached. You open it Tuesday morning before your first class.

No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid.

Art teachers get paid for critiques online by charging for the look itself. A student sends a straight-on photo of their drawing or painting, the reference they worked from and the one thing that bothers them, and you send back ranked fixes in writing, often with a red-line paint-over or a three-value thumbnail drawn on a copy of their image. On Brillay that's a Custom Work listing with your price and a delivery time of up to five days, and an art school applicant orders a portfolio review the same way with a numbered PDF. Technique questions that need no image, like "why does my graphite shine?", fit a Paid Question you answer in writing.

What are students really asking when they DM you a drawing?

The question in the message is rarely the real problem. That gap is what you're selling. Here's what usually turns up when you look:

  • "Why does this face look off? I measured everything." The eye line usually sits too high and the cranium is too small. Or the features are drawn as symbols (an almond eye, a triangle nose) instead of the shapes in the reference. Comparative measurement and a plumb line through the inner corner of the eye usually show it in seconds.
  • "My painting looks flat." Almost always values. Everything is a midtone, with no clear darkest dark and no light shape grouped big enough to read. A grayscale version of their photo proves it to them faster than any explanation.
  • "Why do my watercolors turn muddy?" Three or more pigments in one mix, complements stirred together into grey, a wet layer worked back into before it dried, or a dry wash scrubbed until the paper pilled.
  • "The skin looks grey" or "the skin looks orange." They darkened the shadow with black, or kept light and shadow the same temperature, so the warm-light, cool-shadow shift never happens.
  • "Is the perspective wrong? The buildings feel like they're tipping." Verticals converging when the eye level doesn't call for it, or two vanishing points sitting on different horizon lines.
  • "I've done Loomis heads for three months. Am I getting better?" This person wants a progress read and a next step, not a list of errors.

Two groups send most of these. Hobby artists make up the first: adults who picked up a sketchbook again, retirees starting watercolor, teens drawing on an iPad after school. The second is applicants to art and design schools, who are covered in their own section below. Both want a trained eye on work they made. That's a different job from drawing something for someone. If commissions are your main business, the artists and illustrators page covers that side.

Which critique offers should an art teacher list first?

Start with two or three. Each one has to fit a single order: Brillay delivery times run 1–24 hours or 1–5 days, five days at most, with no milestones or built-in revision rounds.

1. Written critique of one piece (Custom Work)

  • Includes: what's working, three fixes ranked by impact, and one exercise for the biggest one.
  • Student sends: a daylight photo of the whole piece, the reference (or "from life" or "from imagination"), medium, surface, size, and their one question.
  • Delivery: two or three days.
  • Price: you set it. A common starting point is $25–40.

2. Critique with a paint-over (Custom Work)

  • Includes: the written notes plus one or two images marked on a copy of their photo. That could be the corrected jaw and eye line in red, a three-value notan of how the lights and darks could group, or a quick temperature correction on the shadow side. You can add a screen recording talking through it. A delivery takes up to 5 files, and video can run up to 20 minutes.
  • Student sends: the same as above, with the reference at full resolution so your corrections line up.
  • Delivery: three to five days.
  • Price: a common starting point is $45–75.

3. One technique question (Paid Question) A Paid Question is one private question with up to two follow-ups, answered in writing inside the reply time you set. It's text only in both directions, so keep it for things you can answer without seeing the work: "Which paper won't pill when I layer watercolor?", "My gouache dries darker than I mix it. How do I compensate?", "What's a good limited palette for skin in oils?", "How do I stop graphite shine in the darks?"

  • Delivery: 24 hours is common.
  • Price: a common starting point is $10–20.

If the answer depends on looking at their drawing, point them to the critique listing instead.

4. Four-week practice plan from recent work (Custom Work)

  • Includes: from three to five recent pieces, the one or two fundamentals holding them back, plus a four-week plan of exercises such as value scales, 30-second and 2-minute gesture sets, box-and-cylinder drills and a master copy. You say how long to spend on each and what to send back for a check-in.
  • Student sends: up to 5 recent pieces, their goal (portraits, landscapes, comics, a portfolio), and the hours per week they really have.
  • Delivery: four or five days.
  • Price: a common starting point is $50–90.

The check-in after four weeks is a new order, and it's often the one students want most.

What does a finished critique listing look like?

Every Custom Work listing has a title, a description, what the student gets, what you need from them, what's excluded and a delivery time. Here's a filled-in version you can adapt:

  • Title: Critique and paint-over of one drawing or painting
  • What you get: Written notes on what's working, three fixes ranked by impact, one paint-over image on a copy of your photo showing the biggest correction, and one exercise to practice it.
  • What I need from you: A straight-on daylight photo of the whole piece, your reference photo (or tell me it's from life or imagination), medium, surface, size, roughly how long it took, and the one thing that bugs you most about it.
  • Not included: Redrawing or finishing your piece, reviewing pieces not attached to this order, or any marks meant to go into work you'll submit or have graded.
  • Delivery time: 4 days.

The student writes their brief, attaches up to 5 files and pays before you start. You never have to message back asking for the reference.

How do you critique a drawing from a phone photo?

Half of a good online critique is a usable photo. Put these instructions in "what I need" so orders arrive ready:

  • Window light, no glare. Warm lamps turn whites yellow. Graphite, oil and varnish catch light, so tilt the piece slightly or shoot from a little higher.
  • Square on, edges in frame. A tilted phone skews the exact proportions you're about to judge. Keep the borders in.
  • The reference, or how it was made. A copy from a photo, a drawing from life and an invented character are judged differently.
  • Medium, size, time. A 20-minute ballpoint sketch and a 30-hour charcoal portrait need different notes.
  • Level and goal. "First year drawing, want better faces" and "applying to illustration programs this fall" are different critiques.
  • For digital work, a flattened PNG or JPG export. You're critiquing the image, not their layers.

Add one honest line: you critique what the photo shows. Phone cameras shift hue and compress values, so keep your sharpest notes on structure, value grouping and edges, which survive a bad photo far better than colour does.

How do you write a critique a beginner will actually use?

Go from big to small, the same order you'd teach in the studio:

  1. Big shapes and proportion. The envelope, the head-to-body ratio, the eye line, the tilt of the shoulders.
  2. Values. Squint. Does the piece read as three or four grouped shapes, or as scattered mid-greys?
  3. Edges. Where a soft or lost edge would turn the form and where one hard edge should pull the eye.
  4. Colour. Temperature shifts, saturation dropping into the shadows, and mud from overmixing.
  5. Detail. Last, and only if the first four hold up.

Stop at the first layer that's broken. Fixing eyelashes on a head whose cranium is a third too small teaches nothing.

For the paint-over:

  • Work on a copy at reduced opacity, so the student sees the direction (the jaw dropped a quarter inch, the shadow shape merged into one) and does the redrawing themselves.
  • Correct one or two things per image. Fix everything and they see your drawing instead of their mistake.
  • Name the principle. "The eye line usually falls near the halfway mark of the head" travels to the next drawing. "The face feels off" doesn't.
  • Open with what works and cap the list. Adult beginners often quit after a wall of red. Three fixes they can act on beat twelve they'll ignore.

How do you sell art school portfolio reviews?

Portfolio review is a separate business inside art teaching, with its own buyers, calendar and worries.

Who buys. Mostly high school seniors applying to BFA programs, with a parent often paying. Also transfer students, adults applying to illustration, animation or industrial design programs, and younger students applying to pre-college summer programs. Many of them got a few minutes at a National Portfolio Day table and want notes they can reread while they rework.

What they ask. Selection ("which 15 of my 28?"), sequencing ("what opens, what closes?"), balance ("too much digital, not enough drawing from observation?"), whether sketchbook pages belong, whether fan art of existing characters counts, whether a piece answers a school-specific prompt such as RISD's Assignment, and how to title and caption each image for the upload.

When they ask. Close to deadlines, in a rush. Early deadlines at many US art schools fall in November, and regular deadlines come in winter. Your longest window is five days, so put it in the listing: "Order at least a week before your deadline."

How files arrive. A Custom Work order takes up to 5 files, so ask for one numbered PDF with each piece's title, medium, dimensions and year. The target schools go in the brief. A link to a shared folder in the brief works too.

Three offers cover most of it:

  • Written review of a 12–20 piece portfolio. Notes on every piece (keep, cut or rework, and why), a read of what the whole set says about the applicant, and what's missing for their target schools, such as more drawing from life or visible process. Delivery four or five days. You set the price; full reviews commonly start around $120–200.
  • Piece selection and order advice. From up to 30 candidates, which 12–20 to submit and in what sequence, with one line per choice. A strong observational piece usually opens, the most personal one closes, and three similar portraits don't sit side by side. Delivery two or three days; a common starting point is $60–100.
  • Artist statement feedback. Comments on their draft: whether it says something only they could say, where it slides into lines every admissions reader has seen ("I've loved art since I could hold a crayon"), and whether it fits the word limit. Delivery two or three days; a common starting point is $30–50.

Put this on every portfolio listing: No guaranteed admission; the applicant makes their own portfolio work. On the statement listing, add: No guaranteed admission; the applicant writes their own essays. You comment on their draft, you don't rewrite it. Parents who read that before paying trust you more, not less.

AP Art and Design students ask the same kinds of questions about their Sustained Investigation. Critique it the same way, but say plainly that you never complete graded work for a student: the art and the written evidence stay theirs.

If your followers are working designers rather than applicants, the designers page covers job portfolios, and how to charge for "can you review my portfolio?" goes deeper on pricing reviews.

How much should an art teacher charge for a critique?

You set the price. Price the time you actually spend looking, marking up and writing, plus what your training is worth. A one-piece written critique might take 15 minutes. A paint-over with a walkthrough takes longer, and a 20-piece portfolio can take an afternoon. Price them differently.

Rough starting points: $10–20 for a technique question, $25–40 for a one-piece critique, $45–75 with a paint-over, $50–90 for a practice plan, $60–100 for selection and order, and about $120–200 for a full portfolio review. Adjust for your credentials, your audience and how fast you deliver. These are places to start, not a promise of what you'll earn. Raise them when orders arrive faster than you can fill them.

On cost: No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.

Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and followers pay by card from anywhere, which helps when international applicants find you. The details are on Pricing.

Why sell critiques this way instead of booking lessons?

A live lesson is the right tool for teaching a technique in real time. It's the heavy tool for "is my eye line too high?" The student has to find a slot, you hold an hour, and a ten-minute look gets priced like a full session, so most people never book.

Agreeing on price in DMs and sending a payment request has its own snag: you still have to chase the photo and the reference afterwards. With a published listing, the price, scope and delivery time are set once. The student reads them, writes the brief, attaches the files and pays as a guest without making an account, on your own page. It's all asynchronous (no live call), so an applicant in another time zone orders at midnight and you reply between classes.

What about followers who only watch your demos?

Plenty of people follow your value studies and color-mixing videos without ever wanting feedback.

  • Tips let them send a one-time thank-you for a demo that finally made glazing click, with nothing for you to deliver and no membership to join.
  • Goals suit one named purchase for your teaching, like an overhead camera rig for cleaner demos or a model fee for a figure-drawing stream. Followers make one-time contributions toward it, with a progress bar. Every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, there's no deadline unless you set one, and there's nothing to ship.
  • Personalized Videos let a parent order a congratulations video for a student whose acceptance letter just came, or a pep talk the week a portfolio is due. You set the price and the delivery time.
  • Brand Collaboration Inquiries give paper, paint and tablet companies a Work with Me form that sends their budget, timeline and deliverables to a separate brand inbox, away from student orders.

How do you start this week?

  1. Pick two offers. A one-piece critique and a technique question cover most hobby requests. Add the portfolio review and selection offers before application season.
  2. Paste the photo instructions into "what I need" so no order arrives without its reference.
  3. Publish your policies. You write a support policy, a correction and revision policy and a refund policy, and the student sees them before paying. Say what counts as a correction (you misread their question) and what's a new order (a second critique of the reworked piece).
  4. Set delivery times you can keep in your busiest teaching week, not your quietest.
  5. Choose your public name. Followers see it on your page, at checkout and on their receipt. Your legal name is used only for identity verification and payouts.
  6. Answer the next "what's wrong with my drawing?" with one line: "I do full critiques with a paint-over here," and your link.

When you're ready, create your Brillay page.

Frequently asked questions

Can I promise a student they'll get into art school?

No, and your listing should say so: no guaranteed admission; the applicant makes their own portfolio work. You can say how strong the portfolio is, what to cut and what's missing. The decision belongs to the school, and the work has to be the applicant's.

Can a student attach a photo to a Paid Question?

No. Paid Questions are written text in both directions, with no attachments. Keep them for materials, techniques and practice habits. Anything you need to see belongs in a Custom Work critique, where the student attaches up to 5 files.

What if the student reworks the piece and wants another look?

There are no built-in revision rounds. After you deliver a Custom Work order, the student can open a support conversation on that order, choose a reason such as "Correction or revision," and you handle it under the correction policy you published. A full critique of the reworked piece works best as its own order. Some teachers add a lower-priced "second look" listing for exactly this.

Can I send a video critique instead of writing one?

Yes, as Custom Work. A delivery can include a written note, up to 5 files and links, and video or audio can run up to 20 minutes. Many teachers record a short screen walkthrough of the paint-over and add a written summary the student can keep beside the easel.

What does Brillay cost an art teacher?

Nothing to set up and nothing monthly. The only cost is the small platform fee described in the pricing section above, charged only on orders that are actually paid, plus separate card processing.

Will students and parents see my real name?

They see the public name you choose on your page, at checkout, on their card statement and on their receipt. Your legal name goes only to the payment processor for identity verification and payouts.

Start getting paid for the questions and requests you already get

Create your free Brillay link. No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.

Create your free Brillay link