Band and orchestra teachers get paid online for audition help by charging per excerpt in the weeks between a packet's release and the audition date. A parent, or an adult returning to community band, sends one take of the all-state etude or chair-test passage with the cut marked, and the order is paid before you listen. What goes back is measure-numbered notes and a marked part, on a turnaround you set, with time left to practice them. Questions that need no recording, like a reed that won't respond or a bowing in measure 12, fit a Paid Question you answer in writing.
That's the whole model. The rest of this page is about making it work the way your trade actually runs: packets released on a fixed date, a few weeks of frantic practice, and parents who suddenly realize their kid has never had a private teacher's opinion on the Rose etude.
Why does audition feedback sell better per excerpt than per lesson?
Because the deadline creates the need. A family that would never commit to weekly private lessons will happily pay for one expert listen when the region honor band audition is ten days away and the student is unsure about the tempo, the dynamics or the slurs in the cut. They don't want a 45-minute video call booked three weeks out. They want someone who knows the etude to hear this take and say what to fix first.
Selling per excerpt also matches how audition material is built. Most state and region packets have one or two prepared etudes, a set of scales (often including a chromatic scale over a stated range), and sight-reading. Orchestra auditions add orchestral excerpts for strings. School chair tests use a passage from the concert music. Each one is a natural unit: one recording in, one set of notes out.
For you, it means work that fits around rehearsals, sectionals and your own gigs. You listen when the house is quiet, write the notes and mark the part. Nobody waits in a video call.
What should you sell first, and what does each include?
Start with two or three listings, not ten. These fit almost every band and orchestra instrument.
1. Audition excerpt feedback (Custom Work). One recording of one etude, excerpt or scale set from the packet. You deliver written notes ranked by priority (pitch and rhythm first, then tone, then style and dynamics), with measure numbers on every comment, and the student's part marked with fingerings, bowings, breath marks or alternate positions. Many teachers add a short phone demo of the two hardest bars. This is your core offer, sold as Custom Work: you write the scope once, and the parent sends a brief and up to 5 files and pays before you start.
2. Full packet review (Custom Work). All the prepared material for one audition, usually one or two etudes plus the scales. Scope it plainly so it fits in one order. If the packet is long, sell the etudes plus scales and include sight-reading tips as a short written section, not a full mock audition.
3. Quick written answers (Paid Questions). For anything that doesn't need you to hear the student: "Is a 2.5 reed right for a ninth grader?", "Should she shift or stay in fourth position in measure 8?", "The marking is quarter = 120 and he can play it at 96. What's realistic in two weeks?" A Paid Question is one private question answered in writing, with up to two follow-ups, and you choose a reply time of 1–24 hours or 1–5 days. Paid Questions are text only, so recordings go through the Custom Work listing.
4. A practice plan for the weeks before the audition (Custom Work). The student sends a recording of where they are now, plus the audition date. You send back a week-by-week plan: slow-practice targets, metronome steps, which scales to drill daily, and when to start recording full mock run-throughs. This sells well right after packets are released, before anyone has a polished take.
Once the core offers are working, you can add extras. A Personalized Video can be a pep talk the night before all-state or a congratulations after a student makes first chair. Tips let players thank you for the free scale-fingering chart or warm-up sheet you already post, with nothing for you to deliver. A Goal can fund something specific, like a better microphone for your demo recordings. Every Goal contribution is yours whether or not the target is reached, and there's nothing to ship.
What should a parent send with the recording?
Good feedback starts with a usable brief. Put these fields under "what I need from you" in your Custom Work listing so parents fill them in at checkout:
- Instrument, grade, and how long the student has played.
- Which audition: all-state, region or district honor band, youth orchestra seating, school chair test, Solo and Ensemble, or a college pre-screen.
- The exact excerpt: a photo or PDF of the packet page with the cut marked (start and end measures) and the tempo marking.
- The audition date, so you can flag what can't be fixed in time instead of listing everything.
- Anything the student's band or orchestra director has already said about it.
- The recording itself. Followers can attach up to 5 files, each up to 50 MB. A long phone video can be bigger than that, so tell parents they can paste an unlisted video link into the brief instead.
Add simple recording instructions to your listing. For winds and brass: phone on a stand about two meters away, angled to show the embouchure if you plan to comment on it. For strings: a side view that shows the bow arm and the left hand. Ask for a tuning note at the start and one run-through without stopping, because an audition panel hears one take.
How fast should you deliver before an audition?
You choose each listing's delivery time from 1–24 hours or 1–5 days. Five days is the maximum, which suits audition work: a family that orders two weeks out gets your notes with time left to practice them.
A setup that works for many teachers:
- Standard excerpt feedback at 3 days.
- A separate rush listing at 24 hours, priced higher, for audition week.
- A clear line in the description: "Orders placed in the last two days before your audition may not leave enough time to apply the feedback."
Expect surges in the weeks after packets come out, in the run-up to all-state and region dates in your state, and before spring Solo and Ensemble. When concert season buries you, lengthen the delivery time on your listings. There are no milestones and no built-in revision rounds, so each order is one finished package. Write a short correction policy that parents see before they pay, for example: "If I misread the cut, I'll redo that section."
How much should you charge for excerpt feedback?
You set the price. A common starting point for one recorded excerpt with written notes and a marked part is $35–60, depending on its length, your credentials and whether you include a demo recording. Teachers often price a full packet review at $75–120 and a quick Paid Question at $10–25. A 24-hour rush listing often costs $15–25 more than the standard one. Treat these as starting points and adjust once you see how long each order really takes. Nothing here promises a number of orders.
One useful check is your hourly lesson rate. If one excerpt takes you about 30 minutes, including listening twice and marking the part, charge at least half your lesson rate. It's a better deal for the parent than a full lesson, and fair to you.
On cost: No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. The full breakdown is on the pricing page.
How do you handle students who are minors?
Most of your buyers will be parents. When the student is a minor, the parent is the buyer: the parent reads your listing, fills in the brief, sends the recording and pays. Address your notes to the student so they can use them in the practice room, but write knowing a parent reads them first.
A few lines worth putting in every listing:
- Advice and feedback only. No reeds or instruments are shipped.
- Feedback is for practice, with no guaranteed results: no promised chair, rating or all-state spot.
- If the student already has a private teacher or a director working on the same excerpt, your notes are a second opinion, not a replacement.
You also choose the public name followers see on your page, at checkout and on their card statement. Your legal name is used only for identity verification and payouts, which helps if you teach in a school district and want your studio name kept separate.
What changes for string teachers?
String feedback covers the bow arm and the left hand at once, so ask for video, not just audio.
Violin. The most common orchestra instrument and the most crowded audition. Requests center on bow hold, intonation in the upper positions, shifting, vibrato, and the spiccato or détaché passages in the excerpt. Typical offers: feedback on a recording of the packet etude (Kreutzer, Mazas or whatever your state chose) and a custom practice plan up to the audition date.
Viola. Many buyers are youth orchestra parents whose child switched from violin. Their questions are about reading alto clef fast enough for sight-reading, getting used to the bigger instrument and finding a darker sound. Offers: feedback on a recorded etude or orchestral excerpt, orchestra audition prep notes, and an alto clef reading plan for violinists who are switching.
Cello. Posture, endpin height, shifting and bow weight come up constantly. Adult beginners make up a real share of buyers here, alongside students. Offers: written feedback on bow arm and intonation from a video, and fingerings and bowings marked on the part they send.
Double bass. Upright bass players live in two worlds: orchestral excerpts for youth orchestra and all-state, and jazz walking lines for school jazz band. Offers: orchestral excerpt feedback, and a review of a recorded walking bass line over the changes they send, with notes on note choice, time feel and approach tones.
Harp. Lever harp and pedal harp players ask different questions. Pedal harpists ask about pedal settings and changes; lever harpists ask about lever flips and which keys their harp can manage. Offers: feedback on a recorded piece, and a lever-harp arrangement of a requested song. Custom arrangements of copyrighted songs are for the buyer's personal use, and publishing or selling copies needs a license. Say so in the listing.
What changes for woodwind teachers?
Woodwind questions are half playing and half equipment, and the equipment questions are where Paid Questions work best.
Flute. Embouchure, tone and air support, from middle school band students to adults who stopped playing after college. Offers: tone and breathing feedback from a recording, and all-state or audition etude prep notes for the Andersen or Köhler study in the packet.
Clarinet. Crossing the break, throat-tone intonation, reed strength and ligature placement, plus the Rose and Baermann etudes common in band audition packets. Offers: feedback on a recorded audition etude, and reed and embouchure advice in writing.
Oboe. Reed trouble comes up in almost every request. From a recording you can usually tell whether the reed or the player is the problem, then explain how to adjust the reed or what to look for when buying. Advice and feedback only; no reeds are shipped. Offers: tone feedback from a recording, and reed-making advice in writing.
Bassoon. Reeds again, plus tenor clef, the whisper key, flicking and half-hole. Many students switched from another instrument recently and have little time before the audition. Advice only, no reeds shipped. Offers: feedback on a recorded excerpt (often a Weissenborn study), and reed adjustment advice in writing.
Saxophone. Concert band and jazz band are different jobs. Concert players ask about the Ferling etude, vibrato and tone. Jazz players ask about altissimo, articulation and soloing over changes. Offers: tone feedback on a recording and a custom warm-up routine. If you already share a free warm-up sheet, a Tips button lets players send a thank-you.
What changes for brass teachers?
Brass feedback hinges on the embouchure, so ask for a side-angle video. Also ask how long the student had been playing that day, since endurance changes everything.
Trumpet. Range, endurance and lead playing for jazz band, plus marching band season. Offers: a review of a recorded Arban or Clarke study, and embouchure questions answered as Paid Questions ("My chops are gone after 20 minutes. What am I doing wrong?").
Trombone. Slide positions, alternate positions to smooth out a passage, legato tonguing, and tenor and bass clef in advanced etudes such as Bordogni or Blazhevich. Offers: feedback on slide technique and tone from a video, and excerpt or audition prep notes.
French horn. Partials, accurate entrances and right-hand position in the bell, for school and community players. Offers: feedback on a recorded orchestral excerpt, and audition prep notes for etudes like Kopprasch.
Tuba and euphonium. Low-brass breathing, sustaining long phrases, and brass-band repertoire as well as school band music. Offers: feedback on a recorded solo or etude, and audition prep notes. Euphonium players have often switched from trombone or baritone and need help reading treble clef versus bass clef.
What about adult returners and community band players?
Your second-largest group of buyers is adults who played through high school, stopped for twenty years and joined a community band or orchestra. They pay for themselves, ask more questions and rarely have an audition date. They want to know why their tone is thinner than it used to be, whether a new mouthpiece or a new instrument would help, and how to make 30 minutes of practice a day count.
For them, a Paid Question is often the first purchase, and a practice plan is the natural next order. Delivery time matters less, so a longer window is fine.
How do you start?
- Write one Custom Work listing for audition excerpt feedback: what's included, what you need from the parent, the delivery time and the care lines above.
- Add a Paid Questions offer for quick written answers.
- Put your Brillay link in your TikTok or Instagram bio, and mention it when you post about packets coming out.
- Deliver your first order, then adjust the price and turnaround.
Followers pay by card as guests, so parents don't need to create an account. There's no follower minimum, and creators in 41 countries can get paid. See how it works, or read the broader music teachers page if you also teach piano or voice. For audition and recital feedback in general, see selling audition and recital prep feedback. When you're ready, create your free Brillay page.
Frequently asked questions
Can I really give useful feedback from a phone recording?
Yes, on most of what audition panels judge: pitch, rhythm, tempo, articulation, dynamics and phrasing, plus a general picture of the tone. Phone microphones flatten tone quality and exaggerate some noises, so say in your notes what you could and couldn't judge from the recording.
What does Brillay cost a band or orchestra teacher?
There's no monthly fee. A small platform fee applies only when a parent or player actually pays you, and card processing is separate. The exact rates are in the pricing section above.
Can I mark up the excerpt and send it back?
Yes. A Custom Work delivery is one package: a written note, up to 5 files and links. An annotated PDF of the part, a short demo recording and your written notes all fit in one delivery.
Can a student send the whole audition packet in one order?
Yes, if your listing is scoped that way. Each order is one package delivered within the time you set, up to five days, so define the packet review clearly: which etudes and scales it covers, and what it doesn't include.
Do I need a lot of followers to start?
No. There's no follower minimum and nothing to apply for, so it works from the first parent who asks.
Can I sell reeds through my page?
These offers are advice and feedback only, and no reeds or instruments are shipped. Sell reed help instead: a Paid Question about reed strength or adjustment, or a Custom Work order where the student sends a recording and photos of the reed and you explain what to change.
Explore more