Get paid for the questions and custom requests you already get from followers.

Create your free Brillay link

For creators

Beauty educators: get paid to critique new lash, nail, hair and PMU techs

Sell photo critiques and written answers to new lash, nail, hair, barber and PMU techs. They send their work and pay upfront; you set the price and turnaround.

Updated November 2026

Get paid for this β€” with Brillay

Ten DMs in, you finally have her inner-corner close-up, and you still haven't been paid for the retention critique she's waiting on? List it with your price and photo rules, so the next set arrives complete and paid before you open it.

Brillay is a link in your bio where followers pay you directly for:

Custom WorkPaid QuestionsTipsGoalsPersonalized Videos

A barber who just watched your blending reel taps your bio link inside TikTok, attaches a clip of the line he can't blend out and pays by card as a guest. You record a voiceover over his footage Thursday, after your last cut.

No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid.

Beauty educators get paid online by selling critiques to other pros: a new lash, nail, hair, barber or PMU tech uploads photos or a short clip of a service they already did on a client, names what went wrong (retention gone by day five, lifting at the cuticle, a line in the fade, a healed stroke that blurred) and pays upfront for your marked-up written breakdown. When they ask about mapping, developer volume, gel chemistry or what to charge for a fill and there is nothing to look at, they buy one written answer instead. You set the price and the turnaround, and it works from your first follower.

That makes this pro-to-pro mentoring, not consumer beauty advice. The buyer already has a client in the chair; what they want from you is the reason behind the mistake and the fix for the next appointment. On Brillay, the photo critique is a Custom Work listing and the written answer is a Paid Question, both behind one link in your bio. Technique critique only, not a certification or license; follow local licensing rules.

Who actually pays a beauty educator for feedback?

Mostly people in their first two years:

  • Students who finished a weekend lash or nail course, got one live model day, and are now on their own.
  • Newly licensed cosmetologists and barbers on the floor whose salon or shop has no educator, or whose senior stylist is booked solid.
  • Techs adding a service: classic lash artists moving into volume, gel-polish techs learning builder gel structure, colorists starting vivids, brow techs adding powder brows.
  • Techs licensed in one service and training in another, who want a second set of eyes before they raise their prices.

They follow you because your content shows the exact mistake they keep making. What they want next is your eyes on their own work, not another general tutorial. Your full course or in-person mentorship is still the big purchase. A paid critique is the step in between that most of them can afford this month, and it often ends up as the reason they book the course later.

What should a beauty educator sell online first?

Start with two or three offers, not ten. These are the ones that fit the trade.

1. Set or service critique from photos (Custom Work). The tech uploads up to 5 photos of one finished service and answers the questions in your brief. You send back a written critique: what's working, the two or three things costing them the most, and exactly what to change on the next client. You can attach marked-up photos with circles and arrows on the problem areas, up to 5 files in the delivery. A typical turnaround is 2–3 days.

2. Technique video review (Custom Work). This is for barbers, stylists and nail techs whose problem is in the motion, not the result: hand position, clipper angle, sectioning, e-file speed, brush pressure. The tech sends a trimmed clip and you reply with timestamped notes, or a screen-recorded voiceover over their footage (a video in your delivery can run up to 20 minutes). A typical turnaround is 3–5 days.

3. One written question (Paid Questions). For everything that doesn't need you to look at photos: "Why do my volume sets lose bundles in the first week every August?" "Can I mix 20 and 30 volume developer to get something in between?" "What should I charge for a two-week fill when the salon down the road charges $45?" The tech pays upfront to ask one private question, with up to two follow-ups, and you answer in writing on your own time inside the reply window you set. No live call, no scheduling, no time zone to match.

4. Menu and pricing review (Custom Work, optional). New techs underprice. They send their service menu, their area, how many clients they see a week and what local competitors charge, and you send back a note on what to raise, what to drop and how to word their fill policy.

Three smaller tools can sit beside these:

  • Tips. If your free mapping videos got a student through their practical, a Tips button lets them send a one-time thank-you, with nothing for you to deliver.
  • Goals. One named goal with a progress bar, for example mannequin heads and practice strips for a free model day, or a better camera for filming technique close-ups. Every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached.
  • Personalized Videos. A short congratulations video for a student who just passed their state board or opened their first suite. You set the price and delivery time and record it on your schedule.

What should the tech send you so you can actually critique the work?

Bad photos make bad critiques. Put your requirements in the "what I need" part of your listing so every order arrives usable:

  • Lash sets: eyes closed, shot straight on and from above, plus a close-up of the inner corner with the lashes separated so you can see bases, isolation and attachment. Daylight or a ring light, no beauty filter, no editing.
  • Nail sets: a top view of all five, a side profile of each hand to show the apex, an end-on view for the C-curve, and a close-up of the cuticle area.
  • Hair: front, both sides and back under the same light, a before photo, and for color the brand, level, developer volume, processing time and how they sectioned.
  • Barber cuts: finished photos from both sides and the back, plus a clip of the blend under good light.
  • PMU brows: a fresh photo and a healed photo of the same brow at the same angle and light, plus the pigment, the technique (microblading, powder, combo) and how many weeks healed.

Also ask for the product list, the client's starting point (natural lash length and density, nail bed condition, hair history) and the one question they most want answered. That last line keeps your critique focused instead of turning into a full lesson.

Each file the tech uploads can be up to 50 MB, so ask for a trimmed clip of the part they're stuck on rather than a whole 40-minute cut.

One privacy habit worth writing into your listing: ask techs to crop to the work area and to have their client's permission before sending close-ups of eyes or faces. You're reviewing technique, so you rarely need a full face.

How fast do you have to deliver a critique?

You pick the delivery time: 1–24 hours or 1–5 days, with five days as the maximum. Choose it for the week you actually live. If you're behind the chair four days a week, a 3–5 day window lets you batch critiques on your admin day. Paid Questions fit a 24-hour window you can answer between clients.

Each order is one delivery. There are no milestones and no built-in revision rounds, so sell a piece that fits one order: one set, one cut, one healed brow, one portfolio. "Mentor me for three months" doesn't fit; "critique this set" does. That suits how techs improve anyway: fix the two things you flagged, practice on the next client, send the next set as a new order.

For PMU, ask for healed photos taken before they order, since the delivery window starts when they pay and healing takes weeks.

You also write your own Support, Correction and Refund policies, and the tech sees them before paying. After a Custom Work delivery, they can message you on the same order if a file won't open or a point needs clarifying, and you decide how to handle it.

How much should you charge new techs for a critique?

You set the price. New techs often earn little in their first year, so price the critique as the affordable step below your one-to-one mentoring, not as a discount on it. Common starting points:

  • Set or service critique from photos: a common starting point is $35–75.
  • Technique video review: a common starting point is $50–100, since watching footage takes longer.
  • PMU healed-work critique: a common starting point is $60–120, because the stakes are higher and the work is semi-permanent.
  • Portfolio review for makeup artists: a common starting point is $75–150.
  • Paid Question: a common starting point is $15–35.

Full in-person classes and mentorships in this industry often cost hundreds, so a written critique leaves plenty of room above it. Pick a price you'd be happy to do ten of in a week, then adjust once you know how long each one takes you. How many you sell depends on your audience and how clearly you scope the offer.

No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. The full breakdown is on the pricing page.

What does a critique cover, and where does it stop?

Say it plainly in every listing: this is technique critique only, not a certification or license. It isn't a certificate of completion, it doesn't count toward training hours, and it doesn't replace the licensing rules where the tech works. Some services need a license, and some need a health department permit. The tech is responsible for following their local rules.

You're also not diagnosing anything. If a tech describes a client reaction, such as swelling or burning after a lash set, heat or irritation under a gel lamp, or a PMU healing concern, tell them to send the client to a medical professional. You can talk about technique, product handling and following manufacturer instructions, and stop there. And no critique guarantees results, because the next client's eyes, nails, hair or skin will be different.

Hair educators: how do you sell cut and color feedback?

Your buyers are stylists one to three years out of school, assistants hoping to get on the floor, and students preparing for boards. Their questions sound like "why did my balayage band at the mid-shaft," "how do I avoid hot roots taking a level 6 to an 8," "my long layers are uneven at the back," and "my toner went ashier than the swatch."

  • Cut or color technique feedback (Custom Work): front, sides, back and before photos, the formula, and the sectioning pattern. You return notes on saturation, placement, elevation, over-direction and weight line, plus your reasoning on what you'd change in the formula.
  • Formulation question answered (Paid Question): "Level 5 with heavy grey at the hairline, client wants a level 7 copper. Do I pre-soften?" You explain your reasoning; the stylist still does whatever strand and patch tests their manufacturer and local rules require.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules.

Barber educators: how do you review a fade from a video?

New barbers send the same few problems: a visible line in the fade, a dark shadow they can't blend out, too much bulk left on top, an uneven lineup. Most of these show up better in motion than in a still photo.

  • Fade technique video review (Custom Work): a trimmed clip of the blend, finished photos from both sides and the back, and the guards and lever positions they used. You send timestamped notes on angle, flicking, guard progression and where the line formed, or a voiceover over their own footage.
  • Cut critique from photos (Custom Work): for lineup symmetry, crown work and weight line on a finished cut.
  • Clipper setup question (Paid Question): zero-gapping trimmers, blade alignment, which guards to keep in the kit. Remind them to follow the manufacturer's instructions when adjusting blades.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules.

Lash mentors: how do you critique a set from photos?

Lash techs want to know about retention, stickies, heavy inner corners, bundles that won't wrap at the base, and mapping that doesn't suit the eye in front of them.

  • Lash set critique from photos (Custom Work): you look at isolation, attachment and direction, length, curl and diameter choices, symmetry, and whether the map fits the eye shape. Mark up their photos to show exactly which lashes are stuck or sitting off the base.
  • Mapping question answered (Paid Question): "Client has hooded, slightly downturned eyes and wants a cat eye. What do I do?" Doll eye, squirrel, open eye: a written answer they can use at the next appointment.

Retention questions usually come down to prep, adhesive and room conditions, and you can walk through each. If a client reports burning or swelling, the tech sends them to a doctor rather than asking you to diagnose it.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules.

Nail educators: what about set critiques and product chemistry questions?

Nail techs ask about lifting at the cuticle, apex placement, thick sidewalls, flooded cuticles, asymmetric shapes, heat spikes under the lamp and gel that stays tacky.

  • Nail set critique from photos (Custom Work): top view, side profile, end-on view and cuticle close-up. You comment on prep, structure, C-curve, shape and product thickness, and say what to change in their application order.
  • Product chemistry question (Paid Question): "Can I put another brand's top coat over my builder gel?" "Why does my builder wrinkle in the lamp?" You explain how the products behave and point them back to the manufacturer's instructions and safety information. Suspected allergies go to a doctor, not into your answer.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules.

PMU mentors: how do you critique healed brows?

Fresh brows almost always look good. Healed results are where a new microblading or powder brow artist learns whether their depth, spacing and color choice were right, so the healed photo is the heart of the order.

  • Healed-work critique (Custom Work): fresh and healed photos at the same angle, weeks healed, pigment, technique, and the client's skin type (oily, mature, thin). You comment on strokes that blurred or faded, saturation, spacing and how the color healed (too warm, too ashy), and what to adjust at the touch-up.
  • Brow mapping review (Custom Work): a photo of the mapping before they tattoo. A short turnaround works well here, since the tech wants your answer before the client sits down.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules. PMU often needs permits and bloodborne pathogens training where the tech works, and healing questions about the client's skin belong with a medical professional.

Makeup artist mentors: how do you review a portfolio or kit?

This is different from selling face plans to consumers. Your buyers are aspiring artists trying to get booked for bridal, editorial or agency work. They want to know what's holding their book back and what to buy next.

  • Portfolio review (Custom Work): up to 5 images uploaded, or a portfolio link in the brief. You say which images to cut, which gaps to fill (mature skin, deeper skin tones, bridal, clean editorial), and where the lighting or retouching works against them.
  • Kit list review (Custom Work): their current kit, budget and the work they want. You send back what to replace first, which shades are missing, and the hygiene and disposables a working kit needs.

Technique critique only; follow your local licensing rules.

If you also teach consumers, see how to sell an async makeup lesson from your bio link.

How do you set this up this week?

  1. Pick one Custom Work offer that matches what you already critique in DMs most often, such as a lash set critique or a fade video review.
  2. Write the listing: what the tech gets, your photo or video requirements, what's excluded (no certificate, no live call), and a delivery time you can keep. The Custom Work page shows every field.
  3. Add a Paid Question for the text-only questions about mapping, formulas, chemistry and pricing.
  4. Write your Support, Correction and Refund policies so techs know before they pay what happens if a photo was unclear.
  5. Put the link in your bio. The next time someone comments "can you look at my set?", reply with your link instead of a free critique.

How it works walks through an order from both sides. For the bigger picture of selling help as a teacher, see how educators sell personalized help. When you're ready, create your Brillay page.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to be a certified educator to sell critiques?

Rules on who can teach or mentor in beauty vary by state and country, so follow the ones that apply to you, and make your own experience clear on your page: years in the trade, the services you're licensed in, what you teach. Whatever your credentials, what you sell here is technique critique only, not a certification or license.

Can a student send photos with a Paid Question?

Paid Questions are written: one private question, up to two follow-ups, and your written answer. Anything you need to see goes in a Custom Work listing, where the tech submits a brief and uploads up to 5 files. Many educators offer both, so techs choose depending on whether they're asking about something they did or something they're planning.

What if they fix the set and want me to look again?

That's a new order. Each critique is one delivery with no built-in revision rounds, and that matches how techs improve: apply your notes on the next client, then send that set. If something in your critique was unclear, they can message you on the original order after delivery, and your published Correction policy says how you handle it.

Will students see my legal name?

No. Followers see the public name you choose, on your page, at checkout, on their card statement and on their receipt. Many educators use their academy or studio name.

What does Brillay cost me?

There's no monthly fee. The small platform fee only applies to orders that are actually paid, and the exact rates are in the pricing section above.

Can techs in other countries pay me?

Yes. Followers pay by card from anywhere, and creators in 41 countries can get paid. Check that your critique still makes sense for licensing rules and product availability where that tech works.

Start getting paid for the questions and requests you already get

Create your free Brillay link. No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.

Create your free Brillay link