Digital product coaches charge per verdict, not per call: a beginner with a Canva account sends an Etsy link, a planner idea or the sales page of an MRR course, and gets a written read on that one thing. A Paid Question covers a single "is this worth making?" or "is this legit?", and a Custom Work listing covers a full product page or shop review with their stats screenshot attached. You set the price and delivery time, the follower pays before you open anything, and nothing you send promises them income.
Why do your DMs fill up after every "what I'd sell first" video?
Because your audience isn't other experts. It's people with a day job, a Canva account and a few free evenings, who saw someone post a sales screenshot and want to know whether it could work for them. They don't want a course yet. They want one person who knows the market to look at their one thing.
The messages tend to fall into a few shapes:
- "I want to make a budget planner for nurses. Is that too saturated?"
- "Can you look at my Etsy shop? 400 views, 2 sales, I don't get it."
- "Someone in my comments is selling an MRR course for $497 and says I keep all the profit on every resale. Is that real?"
- "Should I sell on Etsy, Stan Store, Payhip or Gumroad first?"
- "Can a faceless account sell an ebook, or do I have to show my face?"
- "Notion template or hyperlinked GoodNotes planner β which one sells better to students?"
- "My product is a $7 ebook. Why is nobody clicking from my bio?"
Each one is a real, answerable question, and each one takes you five to twenty minutes when you do it properly. Answer them free in DMs and you've built a second unpaid job on top of the side business you're coaching people to build.
What do buyers send you, and what do you need from them?
The quality of your review depends on what lands in the order. Ask for it in the offer itself, so nobody pays and then sends "my shop" with no link.
For a single idea or legitimacy question, the follower writes:
- the product idea in one or two sentences (format, niche, who buys it)
- a link to one or two listings they see as competitors
- the link to the MRR, PLR or "done-for-you" offer they're considering, if that's the question
- how many hours a week they actually have
For a product page or store review, they send:
- the link to their Etsy shop, Stan Store, Payhip or Gumroad product page
- a screenshot of their stats (Etsy views and favorites, or bio-link clicks)
- the thumbnail and mockup images they use
- a PDF or view-only Canva link of the product itself, so you can judge what the buyer actually receives
- their price and any coupon or bundle they run
A Paid Question is text only, in both directions, so links get pasted into the question. If you need screenshots or the product file itself, that belongs in a Custom Work order, where the follower submits a brief plus up to 5 files before paying.
Which offers should a digital product coach sell first?
Start with one Paid Question and one or two Custom Work listings. Each one needs a name the follower recognizes from your content, a clear "what you get", and a delivery time you can keep during a busy week or your own launch.
1. "Is this worth making?" or "Is this legit?" β one private check (Paid Question)
This is one offer with one price and one reply time, and it covers the two things beginners ask most. The follower asks one private question about one thing.
It might be an idea: a wedding planner bundle, a meal-prep printable, a Notion template for freelance invoicing. You reply in writing with your honest read: how crowded the niche is, what the strongest listings in it do, what angle you'd take instead, and which format suits that buyer (printable PDF, hyperlinked digital planner, Canva template link, Notion duplicate link).
Or it might be the question beginners are most nervous about and least likely to get a straight answer to. The follower pastes the sales page of the MRR course, PLR bundle or "faceless digital marketing" program they're about to buy and asks whether it makes sense for them. You explain how you read the license terms, what they'd really be selling, who their customer would be, and whether the pitch depends on recruiting the next buyer into the same course.
Either way, they can ask up to two follow-ups, which are usually "what would you name it?", "what price would you test?" or "what should I ask the seller?". A reply time of 24 hours or 2 days works for most coaches. You set the price; a common starting point is $15β$30, because your buyer hasn't sold anything yet.
2. Product page or store review (Custom Work)
Your flagship. Publish the scope in writing: for example, one product listing, or up to five listings in one shop, reviewed for title, thumbnail, first three images, description, price and what the buyer receives. The follower sends the links, a stats screenshot and up to 5 files, and pays before you start. You deliver a written note with fixes in priority order and, if it helps, marked-up screenshots or a screen-recorded walkthrough (a video in a delivery can run up to 20 minutes). Set a delivery time of 3 to 5 days. You set the price; a common starting point is $45β$90 for a single product page, more for a whole small shop.
3. First-product plan (Custom Work)
For the follower who has no product yet. They send their day job, hours available, what people already ask them about, and a link to one product they admire. You deliver a one-to-two page plan: one product to make first, its format, the platform to sell it on, a starting price to test, the free lead magnet that goes with it, and ten content ideas that point people to it. Five days is enough. A common starting point is $60β$120.
4. Resell-rights offer check (Custom Work, optional)
If reading a full license takes real time, don't squeeze it into a Paid Question. Publish it as its own listing, with the sales page and the license as the brief, and deliver a written note on what the terms appear to let the buyer do, what they'd be selling, and what to ask the seller before paying. A common starting point is $30β$60.
The Paid Question is your lowest-priced first step, and people who get a useful answer often come back for the store review.
How do you answer resell-rights and "faceless" questions without making income claims?
This is the part of the niche that gets coaches in trouble, so build the care into your offer text and your answers.
- No guaranteed income. Say it on every offer, in plain words: your review can improve a product and a listing; it doesn't promise sales.
- Be careful with resell-rights (MRR) schemes and income claims. Many MRR programs sell a course whose main product is the right to resell that same course, and the earnings screenshots used to sell it come from people selling it to the next buyer. You can explain how that works, and what the buyer would actually own, without promising that a different model will earn more.
- Don't reuse other people's earnings screenshots as proof, and don't quote numbers you can't back with your own records.
- Flag license problems when you see them: fonts, clipart, Canva elements or brand characters the follower may not be allowed to resell inside a template.
- A license read is your opinion from the terms the follower sends, not legal advice; if real money depends on it, tell them to ask the seller in writing or check with a lawyer.
- Faceless is a format, not a shortcut. A faceless account can sell an ebook or a template; it still needs a real product and a reason to buy.
Often the most honest answer is "don't buy this; make one small product of your own first", and that answer is worth paying for.
How should you price reviews when your buyers are beginners?
Your followers are spending side-hustle money, often before they've earned any. Price the entry offer so it feels like a small, sensible bet, and let the bigger offers carry more of your time.
- Price by time and depth, not by what a coaching package costs. A ten-minute idea check is not a $150 product.
- Keep the steps between offers clear: a Paid Question, then a store review, then a plan.
- Write what's excluded. "One shop, up to five listings, no rewriting your product file" saves you from scope creep.
- Raise prices when the queue fills, not before.
On cost: No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. That matters if you coach people to keep their own costs near zero: you can open a page while your review queue is empty and owe nothing until someone orders. See pricing for the details, and if you're thinking about discounting your first reviews to collect testimonials, read should you discount your first paid offer to build reviews.
What if a follower wants you to fix their whole store?
You'll get "can you just redo my entire shop?" Delivery time is chosen from 1β24 hours or 1β5 days, five days is the most, and each order is one delivery with no built-in revision rounds. So sell a piece that fits one order and say so plainly:
- one listing rewritten, title to last image caption
- thumbnail and mockup direction for one product
- five listings audited, with fixes in priority order
- one launch week of content ideas for one product
If they want the next piece, that's the next order. Write your correction and refund policy when you set up; followers see it before they pay, and after delivery they can message you on the order if a file or link doesn't work.
Side hustle coaches: what changes when the question is "which side hustle should I start?"
If your content covers side hustles in general β digital products, reselling, freelancing, UGC, tutoring β your followers ask an earlier question. Not "is my product good?" but "what should I even do?". They send less: their job, their schedule, their skills, how much they can spend upfront, and whether they need something they can run from their phone.
Two offers fit:
- Answer on one specific idea (Paid Question). "I'm a dental hygienist with three free evenings. Would printable patient-education sheets sell, or is that a dead end?" One idea, one honest read, up to two follow-ups.
- Personalized side hustle plan (Custom Work). They fill in a brief about schedule, skills, starting budget and goals; you deliver a written comparison of two or three options for their situation, with a first step for each.
Be more careful here, because people sometimes ask you whether to quit a job or put savings into an idea. No guaranteed income; not financial advice. You're giving an opinion on a side project, not a plan for their household money. If the question is really about debt or budgeting, a personal finance creator is the better fit.
9-to-5 side hustlers: how do you charge followers who want to copy what you do?
Some of you aren't coaches at all. You post your own job-plus-side-hustle life β the spreadsheet templates you sell, the resume templates, the lesson-plan bundle, the Lightroom presets β and followers ask how to do the same thing.
What's different: they want your skill, not a market review. So sell inside your skill area:
- A Paid Question in your skill area. "How did you price your first teacher bundle?" "What Notion setup do you use to track clients?"
- A custom template or plan (Custom Work). One budget spreadsheet, one Notion dashboard, or one set of planner pages built to their brief, delivered as files or a duplicate link within five days.
Two notes. Check your employer's outside-work policy before you sell anything related to your day job, and keep company tools, files and time out of it. No income guarantees, especially when your own numbers are why people follow you. And if you post under an account name rather than your own, followers see the public name you choose on your page, at checkout and on their receipt; your legal name goes only to Stripe for identity verification and payouts.
How does this fit next to the digital product you already sell?
Most digital product coaches already have a storefront: a $9 guide to your first Etsy product, a niche list, a template pack. That's a file you made once, and every buyer downloads the same one. A review is the opposite: made for one person, from their link, and nothing has to exist before the order arrives.
They work together on the same bio link. People who need the basics buy the guide; people stuck on their own listing buy the review. Followers who got something from a free video can send a one-time thank-you with Tips, with nothing for you to deliver. If you're saving for something specific β a new laptop for template design, a printed planner sample run β a Goal shows a progress bar, and every contribution is yours whether or not you reach it. If you also sell physical products, the ecommerce sellers page covers listing reviews from the Etsy and Shopify side.
How do you start this week?
- Set up your Paid Question for idea and "is this legit?" checks, and publish one Custom Work listing, usually the store review.
- Write each offer's inputs into its description: "Paste your product link and your niche. Tell me how many hours a week you have."
- Write what you won't do: rebuild the product, promise sales, review more than the listed number of listings.
- Set a price and a delivery time you can keep during a normal work week.
- Put the link in your bio and pin a comment on your next "what I'd sell first" video: "Want me to look at yours? It's in my bio."
Creators in 41 countries can get paid, followers pay by card from anywhere, and there's no follower minimum, so a small account starts the same way a large one does. See how it works, read more about Paid Questions and Custom Work, then create your Brillay page.
Frequently asked questions
Can I send a screen recording instead of a written reply?
A Paid Question is answered in writing, which suits idea checks: the follower can reread it while they build the product. For a walkthrough of their listing, use Custom Work, where you deliver a note plus files, including a screen recording of up to 20 minutes.
What does it cost me to run?
Nothing to keep the page live. The fee applies only to orders that are actually paid, at the rates in the pricing section above.
Do followers need an account to order a review?
No. They pay upfront by card as a guest on your page and send their link in the same step.
Can I tell someone a product will make them money?
Don't. Keep every offer and answer to what you can stand behind: whether the idea is clear, the listing is strong, the license terms are clear enough to check, the price makes sense. No guaranteed income, and be careful with resell-rights (MRR) pitches and income claims, including your own.
What if my audience is small?
There's no follower minimum. Fifty engaged followers who keep asking about their Etsy shops are enough for a first order.
Can I sell under my faceless account name?
Yes. Followers see the public name you choose; your legal name goes only to Stripe for verification and payouts.
Explore more