Most music production mentors who get paid online sell two things. The first is a review: a follower sends a bounce, stems or a zipped project file with a short brief, pays upfront, and gets back timestamped mix and arrangement notes or a screen-recorded walkthrough of their session. The second is a written answer to one production question, such as how you built the bass in last week's tutorial or why their sidechain pumps off the beat. On Brillay those are Custom Work and Paid Questions, sold from one link in your bio at the price and delivery time you choose.
What makes production mentoring its own trade is the material. Nobody films their hands. They send a file that only opens if they exported it correctly, made with plugins you may not own, in a DAW version that may be newer than yours. Most of the work of selling reviews is getting that file to arrive usable. If you teach an instrument or voice and get performance clips instead, the music teachers page fits you better.
What are bedroom producers actually asking you for?
The requests in your DMs and comments repeat:
- "My melodies are good but my 808s sound muddy." Usually the kick and 808 fight below 100 Hz, the 808 is out of key, or the pads and reverb returns were never high-passed.
- "Why does my drop have no energy?" Often the breakdown is already as loud and full as the drop, so there is no contrast left to release.
- "How did you make that sound?" from someone who watched your tutorial and wants the exact chain.
- "Sounds great in my headphones, terrible in the car." A low-end and mono question in disguise.
- "Is this ready to release?" from someone uploading to a distributor next Friday.
- "I can't afford a course, can you just look at one track?" from a beginner on a small budget.
The worries run both ways. The producer worries about sending an unreleased track to someone who never replies. You worry about opening project after project that loads with missing samples, and about "can you take a quick listen" turning into an hour of free mixing. A published offer with a scope, a price and a list of what you need settles both.
What should a music production mentor sell first?
Start with two or three offers, not ten:
1. Track critique with timestamped notes (Custom Work). The follower sends a bounce, their genre, one or two reference tracks and the one thing that bothers them most. You send back notes keyed to timestamps ("0:48: the snare disappears when the supersaw enters; 1:32: the build and the drop sit at the same level") and the three fixes that matter most, ranked. Two to three days is a common delivery time.
2. Project-file review with a screen-recorded walkthrough (Custom Work). The follower sends the project with samples collected, their DAW version and a list of third-party plugins. You record yourself walking through routing, gain staging, arrangement and mix decisions, and send the recording with a written summary. Three to five days suits most mentors.
3. Release-readiness check (Custom Work). Before a song goes to a distributor: integrated loudness and true peak, clicks at edit points, mono compatibility of the low end, intro length, a clean fade, noise in the tails. You deliver a checklist with timestamps for anything that fails.
4. One production question (Paid Question). For anything that does not need you to hear their track: a technique, a setting, a workflow problem.
If you also build racks, templates or devices, a scoped build is a natural fifth offer. The software sections below cover those.
How do you make sure the project file actually opens?
Put your requirements in the listing's "what I need" field so the follower reads them before paying. A follower can attach up to 5 files of 50 MB each, which covers a bounce and a reference in most cases. A full project with stems and samples is usually bigger, so ask for a cloud folder link in the brief.
Ask for the project the way each DAW packages it:
- Ableton Live: Collect All and Save, then zip the project folder.
- FL Studio: export the project data files as a zip, so the samples travel with the .flp.
- Logic Pro: save the project with audio files copied into it.
- Pro Tools: Save Copy In, with audio files included.
Then handle plugins before they become your problem. Ask the follower to freeze and flatten, bounce in place or commit any track that uses a third-party synth or effect, keeping a muted copy of the original. Ask for their exact DAW version, because a project saved in a newer version may not open in an older one. And ask for a mix bounce with the master limiter off as well as their loud version, so you can judge the mix and the mastering separately.
What do you send back?
A Custom Work delivery is one package: a written note, up to 5 files of up to 500 MB each, and links. A video in the delivery can run 20 minutes or shorter, which is the right length for a focused walkthrough anyway. Delivered files stay available for 90 days, so tell the follower to save the recording.
A structure that works:
- What already works, in a line or two, so they know what not to touch.
- The top three fixes, each with a timestamp and a concrete action ("cut the pad 3 dB around 250 Hz under the vocal", not "clean up the mids").
- Arrangement notes: where energy sags, where a section runs four bars long, where the drop needs a beat of silence before it lands.
- One thing to practice on the next track.
Some mentors return a copy of the project with a few changes on duplicated tracks so the follower can A/B the two. That is still teaching. Mixing the whole song for them is a different service with its own price.
When is a Paid Question better than a review?
A Paid Question is one private question, answered in writing, with up to two follow-ups. It is text only, so it suits questions you can answer without hearing their track:
- "How do I sidechain only the low end of my bass?"
- "What did you put on the vocal chop in your last video?"
- "Why does my CPU spike when I add a third instance of my synth?"
The follow-ups matter. The usual second message is "I tried it and now the pumping is too obvious", and you answer it in the same thread instead of a new DM. You choose the reply time from 1β24 hours or 1β5 days. It is also the honest entry point for a beginner on a small budget: one clear answer for less than a full review, asynchronous (no live call) on both sides.
When a Paid Question really needs a listen ("what's wrong with my mix?"), answer what you can and point them to your critique listing.
How long should a review take to deliver?
You choose from 1β24 hours or 1β5 days; five days is the maximum. Set the window you can keep in your busiest week. If you release your own music or teach at a school, reviews stack up on the same weekends, and a three-day window with critiques done in batches is easier to keep than 24 hours. Paid Questions can run faster, because one written answer fits between sessions.
How much should you charge for a track critique or project review?
You set the price. A common starting point is around $10β25 for a Paid Question, $25β60 for a written critique of one track, $60β150 for a project-file walkthrough, $30β50 for a release-readiness check, and $40β150 for a custom rack or template, depending on complexity. These are starting points, not a promise of what you will earn.
Price by what you have to open, not by song length. A bounce takes a few listens. A project means loading it, chasing missing plugins, checking routing and recording a walkthrough, so it should cost more for the same three-minute track. If your tutorials are known in one genre, your notes are worth more there than general advice.
No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.
The full breakdown is on the pricing page.
Can you still sell ongoing mentorship?
Yes, one scoped piece at a time. Each order has one delivery, with no milestones or built-in revision rounds, so a ten-week course does not fit in one order. What fits is one unit of it: one track reviewed, or this week's assignment ("finish an eight-bar loop and send the bounce") reviewed with notes and next week's task. A follower who wants weekly mentoring orders again each week.
Write a short correction and revision policy, such as "I'll re-check one fix you've applied within 14 days", and a refund policy; followers see both before paying. On Custom Work, the follower can also contact you about the order after delivery through its support conversation. Be plain that a review improves the track with no guaranteed results: no label signing, playlist add or stream count comes with it.
What do Ableton Live teachers sell?
Ableton teachers get the most "how did you do this?" questions, because their tutorials show racks and devices people want to copy: Instrument and Audio Effect Racks with macros, Max for Live devices, Session versus Arrangement View, warping.
- Review of your Ableton project file. Ask for Collect All and Save plus the Live version and edition. Max for Live devices need Suite or the add-on, so ask a Standard user to freeze any track that depends on one.
- Custom rack or template for your workflow. Scope it to one deliverable: "one Audio Effect Rack for vocal chops with eight macros mapped, as an .adg file with a note on each macro", or "a live-set template with your track layout and returns". State which Live version it is built in.
If you give away Max for Live devices, such as the sidechain device you teach people to build, a Goal can fund the next one.
What do FL Studio mentors sell?
FL Studio buyers are often beginners making trap, drill and hip-hop, stuck on the pattern and playlist workflow: patterns duplicated instead of reused, everything routed to the master insert, no group mixer tracks. The most common mix question is the muddy 808.
- Written review of your project file. Ask for the .flp with zipped project data files and the FL version. Check Channel Rack routing, mixer inserts, the piano roll and how the playlist is arranged.
- Mix notes for muddy 808s. A narrow, popular offer: tuning the 808 to the key, glide notes that clash, kick and 808 overlap, ducking, saturation so the 808 shows up on phone speakers, and a mono sub. A bounce plus the 808 sample is often enough, so it can cost less than a full review.
What do Logic Pro teachers sell?
Logic buyers are often Mac singer-songwriters recording their own vocals and guitar and arranging around them. They ask about comping takes, Flex Pitch and Flex Time, Drummer and Session Players, Track Stacks, and why the vocal sits on top of the mix instead of inside it.
- Review of your Logic session. Ask for the project saved with audio files copied and the Logic version. Check the vocal comp, the arrangement around the topline, bus routing and the vocal chain.
- Template set up for your genre. A starting session with Track Stacks, buses, a vocal chain and drums, built with stock plugins so it opens on any Mac with Logic.
What do Pro Tools tutors sell?
Pro Tools buyers are home-studio engineers and audio students, and their problems are often technical before musical: playback engine and buffer errors, I/O setup, missing files after moving a session, playlist comping, clip gain versus automation, Elastic Audio.
- Session troubleshooting answer (Paid Question). They describe the error message, interface and buffer size; you answer in writing, and the follow-ups cover "tried that, still happens".
- Editing workflow review (Custom Work). They send a Save Copy In session or a screen recording of their edit; you return notes on crossfades, comping, Smart Tool use and the shortcuts that save hours.
For students, you review their own session and explain your reasoning. You never complete graded work for a student.
What if you teach more than one DAW?
Gain staging, EQ, compression and arrangement transfer between programs. If you are software-agnostic, sell the review on the bounce, which needs no particular DAW, and offer project-file reviews only for the programs you own, named in the listing. Producers switching programs ("moving from FL to Ableton, what changes?") fit Paid Questions well.
A custom Max for Live device fits too: one device with one job, delivered as a file with a short note inside the five-day window, with the listing saying it needs Suite or the add-on.
What do film scoring mentors sell?
Aspiring film and game composers send a cue against picture or a demo reel, not a song. They ask about spotting, hitting cuts, tempo maps, whether a mockup sounds believable with their sample libraries, and whether the score fights the dialogue.
- Feedback on a scored scene. Ask for the clip with timecode burned in, as a link. Return notes by timecode: where the cue hides a line of dialogue, where it misses the cut, where the strings sound like samples.
- Composer demo reel review. Comment on order, the first 30 seconds, genre range, and which cues to cut.
"What should I charge for game music?" makes a good Paid Question from this group, with follow-ups about their specific project.
What about tips, goals and brand inquiries?
Tutorial makers have an audience that learns for free and wants to give something back.
- Tips are a one-time thank-you after your free template or tutorial helped, with nothing to deliver. If you produce live, see accepting tips during a Twitch music production stream.
- Goals name one target, such as "the next free tutorial series" or "new monitors and acoustic panels", with a progress bar. Every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, there is no deadline unless you set one, and nothing ships. See what to put on a goals page.
- Brand Collaboration Inquiries give plugin developers and sample-pack companies a Work with Me form that collects budget, timeline and deliverables into a separate brand inbox.
- Personalized Videos are the smallest fit: a congratulations video when a student releases a first track.
How do you start?
- Create your page and choose your public name. Followers see that name, such as your producer alias, not your legal name.
- Add one Custom Work listing for your track critique, with your file requirements in "what I need".
- Add Paid Questions for production questions.
- Put the link in your bio and pin it under your next tutorial: "Want me to review your track? Send it here."
- When the next "can you check my mix?" DM arrives, reply with the link.
There is no follower minimum, and creators in 41 countries can get paid. Create your Brillay page and publish the first listing today.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to own every plugin the producer used?
No. Ask in your listing for any track using a third-party plugin to be frozen, bounced in place or committed to audio, with the original kept muted. You can then hear and move everything, and comment on their settings from a screenshot or description.
Can a follower send a full project with all the stems and samples?
They can attach up to 5 files of 50 MB each with the brief. Larger projects should come as a cloud folder link written in the brief, packaged the way their DAW collects samples.
What if they want me to mix the track for them?
That is a mix, not a review. If you offer mixing, publish it as its own Custom Work listing with its own price and scope. If you only teach, say so and keep the review to notes, a walkthrough and a few A/B examples.
How much does Brillay cost?
There is one free plan with no monthly fee. You pay only when a follower pays you, at the rates set out in the price section above.
Do I need a big following to start?
No. There is no follower minimum and nothing to apply for, so it works from the first producer who asks you to hear their track.
Will a review get the track signed or onto playlists?
No guaranteed results. A good review shows the producer what to fix and why; say plainly in your listing that it promises no signing, placement or streams.
Explore more