Playlist curators get paid by independent artists for the listen and the written verdict, never for the spot on the playlist. You publish a track review at a price you set. The artist sends one track, the playlist they're aiming for and a few reference songs, pays upfront, and gets your timestamped notes back within the delivery time you chose. Whether that track ever gets added stays your own decision, made for free, the same way you decide on every other song.
Can I charge for submissions without selling playlist placement?
Yes. The artist pays for your time, your taste and your writing, and nothing about your playlist. Spotify's rules do not allow anyone to accept payment in exchange for adding a track to a playlist. Paid placement breaks those rules, and so does anything that promises streams. Curators caught doing it can lose their playlists, and artists whose songs land on bought or botted lists can have streams removed. A review is a different product: one informed listener's opinion of one track, delivered whether the answer is "pitch it" or "not yet."
Hold yourself to one rule: sell reviews only; never guarantee placement, streams, coverage or a signing.
Put that rule in the listing so nobody can read it any other way:
- "You're paying for a written review of one track. Feedback only; no paid playlist placement."
- "Buying a review does not change whether I add your song, in either direction."
Then back it up with how you actually work. Judge adds by the same standard whether a track came through a paid review, your free submission form, or your own digging on Bandcamp and SoundCloud. Many curators keep a free submission lane open next to the paid review, so nobody has to pay to be considered: "free gets a listen; paid gets the reasons."
Why would an artist pay when they could pitch for free? Because a pass with no reason teaches them nothing. An artist who pitches a debut single to twenty curators mostly gets silence or "not a fit, best of luck." They want to know why. Did the vocal arrive too late? Was the master crushed? Was a 128 BPM four-on-the-floor track pitched to a late-night acoustic list? You hear this every day. They hear it from you once, in writing, with timestamps.
What does a paid track review from a curator actually look like?
Post a short sample review on the social accounts where artists already find you, such as a pinned post on Instagram or TikTok, because it answers "what am I buying?" faster than any description. Your Brillay page holds the offer itself; the sample lives on your socials. Here is the shape of a useful one, for a final master pitched at a late-night indie playlist:
0:00β0:22, intro. Rain field recording and a pad. On a list where most songs reach a vocal inside ten seconds, a shuffle listener is gone by 0:15. A stream only counts after 30 seconds, so this is where you lose them. Try an edit that starts at 0:14.
0:41, doubled vocal. The double is louder than the lead for two bars and pulls focus. Ask your engineer to tuck it about 2 dB.
1:28β1:58, chorus. The best 30 seconds of the song. Build the intro edit around getting here sooner.
Loudness. The master is pushed very hard. Streaming normalization turns it down, and next to the quieter references you sent, the chorus loses its lift.
Fit. At this tempo, with that kick, it sits more naturally beside indie-dance and night-drive playlists than late-night acoustic ones.
Verdict. Strong song, wrong lane. Fix the intro, rethink the target, then pitch.
Every line can be acted on. Notice what's missing: no promise of an add, no stream estimate, no mention of your own playlist except as a point of comparison.
Which offers should a playlist curator sell first?
Start with two or three, each built around a single track. Put anything that needs audio and a brief into Custom Work. Use Paid Questions for quick questions that only need a written answer.
1. Written review of one track (Custom Work). Your core offer, built like the sample above: a timestamped listen-through, notes on the intro, when the hook lands, vocal level, low end and energy, a comparison with three or four songs from the playlist the artist named, and a one-line verdict. The artist sends the track, its stage (demo, rough mix or final master), the target playlist or three reference tracks, genre and mood tags, and the one thing they're most unsure about. Delivery: 2β3 days. You set the price; a common starting point is $20β50 per track.
2. Playlist-fit feedback (Custom Work). For artists whose song is finished but who don't know where to send it. You tell them which lanes and moods it fits, which songs it would sit comfortably between, where it belongs in a sequence (opener, mid-set lift, wind-down), and whether their genre tags and "fans also like" neighbors point curators in the right direction. The artist sends the track, their artist profile link, and the five to ten playlists they plan to pitch. Delivery: about 3 days. A common starting point is $25β60. Say plainly that this is advice on fit, not a promise that any playlist, yours included, will take the song.
3. Mix notes (Custom Work). Notes for the artist to take back to their engineer, not a mix. Examples: a synth masking the vocal at 1:12, harsh "s" sounds in verse two, a stereo widener that collapses in mono, kick and bass that vanish on earbuds. Ask whether it's a rough mix or the final master, because the notes change completely. A common starting point is $40β90.
4. One quick question (Paid Question). Some questions don't need a full listen. "Which of these two singles should I lead with?" "Is a 35-second intro a dealbreaker for lo-fi study lists?" "My song is 112 BPM with a trap hi-hat. Is it R&B or chill hip-hop for playlist purposes?" A Paid Question is one private question answered in writing, with up to two follow-ups. It's text only, so if you need to hear something, the artist pastes a private streaming or download link into the question. You set the reply window; 24 hours suits most curators. A common starting point is $10β25.
Most curators open with the track review and a Paid Question, then add mix notes once they notice the same problems keep coming up.
What should the artist attach to a submission?
A thin brief makes a thin review. Use the "what I need from you" part of your listing to ask for exactly what you'd want before pressing play:
- The audio. The artist can attach up to 5 files, 50 MB each. A 16-bit WAV up to about four and a half minutes fits; for longer or 24-bit files, ask for a 320 kbps MP3 or a private download link in the brief.
- The stage. Demo, rough mix or final master.
- The target. One playlist by name, or three reference tracks they think it sits beside.
- Whether the release is already locked. If final audio is already with the distributor, fit notes are worth more than mix notes, and you can steer them to the right offer.
- Lyrics, if the song depends on its words or might need an explicit tag.
In the "what's excluded" part, write: "Not included: playlist placement, promotion, guaranteed streams, or posting about your track."
With Custom Work you deliver a written note plus up to 5 files or links, so you can attach a marked-up lyric sheet, a screenshot of a loudness reading, or a spoken walkthrough as an audio file of up to 20 minutes.
How long should a curator take to deliver a review?
You choose the delivery time: 1β24 hours or 1β5 days, and five days is the maximum. For a written review, 2β3 days gives you two fresh listens, one on monitors and one on phone speakers or cheap earbuds, the way most playlist listeners will hear it. A 24-hour option at a higher price suits artists who are about to send their final audio to a distributor.
There are no milestones and no built-in revision rounds, so each order should be something you can finish in one delivery. For an EP, sell one review per track, or a shorter "first impressions of the EP" note covering sequencing and which song should be the focus.
How should I price a track review?
You set the price. Price by depth and turnaround, not by your playlist's follower count. If your review price rises with your reach, it starts to look like you're charging for exposure, which is the line you're trying not to cross.
On pay-per-submission services, the artist pays a small amount per pitch and the curator usually owes a short reply. That fee buys a sentence or two. A timestamped review with a fit verdict is a much bigger job, and it's fine to price it that way. Raise your price once orders arrive faster than you can listen properly twice.
What does it cost you to run? No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. The details are on the pricing page.
No income is promised here. Some weeks bring a dozen orders, some bring none, and release-heavy months tend to be busier.
What if the artist is upset their track wasn't added?
This is the worry curators raise most often. Two things help.
First, write your policies before anyone pays. On Brillay you write your own support policy, correction and revision policy, and refund policy, and the artist sees them before paying. A clear version for a curator: "Refund if I haven't started, or if I reviewed the wrong file. No refund because the track wasn't added, or because you disagree with my opinion." After a Custom Work delivery, the artist can open a support conversation on the order to ask about a note or flag a broken file. You reply, and only you close it.
Second, write reviews that make bad news usable. Start with what works. Timestamp every problem so it can be checked. End with a short fix list, most important first. An artist can argue with "I didn't love it." It's much harder to argue with "the first vocal arrives at 0:48, and on a mellow list most listeners have skipped by then."
I review demos and mixes, not playlists. What changes?
Song and demo reviewers are selling an earlier moment. The artist usually hasn't paid for a mix yet and wants to know whether the song deserves one. The questions are about the song, not the lane: "Does the chorus actually lift?" "Do I need the bridge?" "Is the demo vocal good enough to keep?"
Your two offers are a written critique of one track and mix notes, both as Custom Work. A voice-memo demo and a rough mix need different notes, so ask which one you're getting. If you don't run playlists, drop the fit comparison and spend that time on structure and arrangement. If you do, keep the same wording: feedback only; no paid playlist placement. Teachers who sell timestamped notes on recordings have worked out much of this already; the guide on async feedback from your bio link and the music teachers page carry over well.
I used to work in A&R. Can I charge for demo reviews?
Yes, and your buyers are a little different: artists, and sometimes their managers, who want to know how a label would hear them. The question is "is this label-ready?", not "does this fit a playlist?"
- Honest demo review with release potential notes (Custom Work). Up to three demos plus a one-sheet or EPK, as MP3s or a private link. You tell them where the songs sit against what's coming out in their genre now, which one you'd lead with, and what an A&R would ask next: is there a body of work, is the sound consistent, is there a live show, and is the audience growing on its own or only through ads. A common starting point is $75β150.
- Artist development plan (Custom Work). A written plan scoped to fit one delivery within five days, such as "what to record and release across your next three singles," not open-ended mentoring. A common starting point is $150β300.
Your care line is stricter, because artists will read your background as access. No signing guarantees, and no promised introductions. Describe your experience accurately, and don't name labels or contacts you can't stand behind.
I'm a music critic. Can artists pay me to review their EP?
They can, and critics get two kinds of paying followers.
Artists want an honest written review of a single or EP before release, partly for feedback and partly to hear how a critic hears them. An EP of up to five tracks fits one Custom Work order; for full-resolution masters, ask for a private download link. Make the scope explicit: a private written review delivered to the artist, not a promise to cover the release on your channel or blog. Paid reviews are honest feedback, not guaranteed coverage. If you ever publish a review someone paid for, disclose it as paid content in the post or video, and use your platform's paid-promotion label where there is one.
Listeners want personalized album recommendations, which suits a Paid Question: "I've had Big Thief on repeat all year. What should I hear next that isn't folk?" You reply with five picks and a reason for each, and the two follow-ups cover "I already know that one."
Where do Tips and Goals fit for a curator?
Listeners who found their song of the year on your playlist often want to say thanks. Tips give them a one-time way to do it, with nothing for you to deliver and no membership for them to join.
Goals suit curators who run listening sessions or showcases for the artists they champion. A Goal called "Spring showcase: venue and sound for six underground acts" shows a progress bar. Followers make one-time contributions, every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, there's no deadline unless you set one, and there's nothing to ship.
Personalized Videos are a weaker fit; if you'd rather review on camera, sell it as Custom Work and attach the video to the delivery. If plugin makers, headphone brands or labels approach you, a Work with Me form for Brand Collaboration Inquiries collects their budget, timeline and deliverables in a separate brand inbox. The same line applies there: a sponsored segment can be disclosed, but an add is never for sale.
How do I start taking paid reviews this week?
- Create your page under the name artists already know, usually your playlist or channel name. Followers see the public name you choose, not your legal name.
- Add a Custom Work offer called "Written review of one track," with what's included, what you need, what's excluded and a delivery time.
- Pin a sample review on your Instagram, TikTok or YouTube so artists can see the format before they order.
- Add a Paid Question for quick fit and release questions, with a 24-hour reply window.
- Write your support, correction and refund policies, including "no refund because the track wasn't added."
- Put the link in your bio, your playlist description, and the auto-reply on your free submission form.
Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and artists pay by card from anywhere with no account. There's no follower minimum, so a list with a few hundred saves can start the same day as one with fifty thousand. Read how it works, then create your page.
Frequently asked questions
Is charging for a submission review the same as paid placement?
No. Paid placement means money buys a spot on the playlist, which Spotify's rules do not allow. A review means money buys your written opinion of one track, and the add decision stays separate and unpaid.
Should I keep a free submission option too?
Many curators do. A free lane where every track gets considered, next to a paid lane where the artist gets the reasons, makes it obvious that money buys feedback and not access.
What if an artist asks for a refund because the review was negative?
Set this out in your refund policy before anyone pays. Most reviewers refund for a wrong file or work not yet started, and not for disagreement or for a track that wasn't added. On Custom Work orders, the artist can raise it in the support conversation after delivery, and you answer and close it.
Do I need a big playlist to charge for reviews?
No. There's no follower minimum and nothing to apply for. Artists pay for your ear and your writing, not your reach.
How much does Brillay cost a curator?
Nothing per month. You only pay the platform fee on orders that actually get paid, at the rates in the pricing section above, and card processing is separate.
Can artists send stems for mix notes?
They can attach up to 5 files, each under 50 MB. A stereo bounce as a 320 kbps MP3 plus two or three short 16-bit stems usually fits. For a full multitrack session, ask for a private download link in the brief.
Explore more