Selling the answer instead of the return is how a tax preparer gets paid for the questions freelancers send between January and April 15: a first 1099-K, a Schedule C deduction, how estimated payments work. List it on Brillay with the facts you need named in your offer text (filing status, state, year-to-date net), and each question lands already paid, ready for you to answer in writing around your returns. Reading a P&L or a stack of 1099s becomes a scoped order such as a limited-scope quarterly planning note, and the return itself stays in your normal engagement.
The rush comes in two waves: late January to April 15, and the weeks before every estimated-tax due date. An Etsy seller wants to know if the spare room counts as a home office. An LLC owner's cousin said to "go S-corp." Below: what to sell, what to ask buyers for, how long to take in peak season, how to price it, and where general tax information ends and preparing a return begins. If your audience mostly asks about budgets, debt and saving rather than 1099s and Schedule C, the personal finance creators page is the better fit.
Which tax questions should you stop answering for free?
Some questions should stay free. "When are quarterlies due?" has a public answer, and posting it is how you build the audience that later pays you. The questions worth charging for take you more than a couple of minutes to think through. The rule has conditions most people misread, and misreading them is expensive.
Typical ones from freelancers, creators and small businesses:
- "I got a 1099-K from PayPal and a 1099-NEC from the brand for the same deal. Am I being taxed twice?"
- "I netted about $40k on Schedule C and haven't paid anything in yet. How do estimated payments and the underpayment penalty work for someone in my position?"
- "Can I deduct my ring light, my phone, and part of my apartment if I film there?"
- "I have a W-2 job and a side business. Can I raise my withholding instead of making estimated payments?"
- "My single-member LLC made $90k. What would Form 2553 actually change, and what counts as a reasonable salary?"
- "A brand sent me a free trip and a box of PR products. Is that income?"
At the center of every one of these is "it depends." Explaining what it depends on, and how the rule generally works for someone in that position, is what a follower pays for. A worked payment figure belongs in a planning note.
Your existing clients create a second stream. In July you get the "quick question" email about buying a truck through the business, whether a new contractor needs a 1099-NEC, or whether a client's spouse can go on payroll. None of that is inside a return engagement. Replying with a Paid Question link instead of a long email sets the boundary for you, with no separate invoice to write. The same logic applies to quick business questions outside tax, as covered in charging for quick business questions from your bio.
What can a tax preparer sell besides a full return?
Two offer types cover almost everything: Paid Questions for answers and Custom Work for anything that means reading documents. Open with two products, then add more once you see what people actually buy.
One tax question answered (Paid Question). This is one private question with a written answer, plus up to two follow-ups so the follower can correct a number or ask "and what about my state?" Paid Questions are text only, so the follower types everything and uploads nothing. Write your offer text to ask for the facts you need right in the question: filing status, state, rough self-employment net profit, whether they also have W-2 wages, and what they've paid in so far this year. Those typed facts only set the context for explaining how the rule generally works; they aren't inputs for calculating a payment or telling the follower what to file. Good fits are 1099-K versus 1099-NEC confusion, whether a type of expense generally belongs on Schedule C, how the rules on who must make estimated payments work, how mileage and the standard rate work, or what an IRS notice they received generally means.
Quarterly planning note (Custom Work). The follower sends year-to-date income and expenses (a P&L export, a spreadsheet, or payout summaries from YouTube, TikTok, Stripe or Shopify) plus the first two pages of last year's Form 1040 with identifying numbers blacked out. You send back a written note covering the prior-year safe harbor compared with a current-year estimate, a worked estimate for each remaining quarter from the figures they supplied, labeled as an estimate, the due dates, how to pay through IRS Direct Pay or EFTPS, and a line on state estimates if their state requires them. Because this note works from their own figures, sell it as a limited-scope engagement under your own terms, and say so in the listing. Freelancers ask for this in April, June, September and January.
S-corp quarterly planning (Custom Work, higher tier). This one is for owners who already run an S-corp or are deciding whether to elect. They send the P&L, how payroll is set up today, and what they currently pay themselves. You deliver a note on how you'd reason about a reasonable salary for their role and profit, how distributions sit next to payroll, the owner's estimated-tax picture for the quarter, and, for owners still deciding, a plain break-even view of whether the election is worth the payroll cost and the extra return. Because this note works from their own figures, sell it as a limited-scope engagement under your own terms, and say so in the listing. Keep the scope to one quarter or one decision.
Document checklist (Custom Work, low price). This works best before the season starts. The follower fills in a short brief: which platforms paid them, any home office, vehicle use, a K-1, crypto, a move between states, new dependents, a new LLC. You send a personalized list of what to gather, which forms to download from each platform's dashboard, and what to ask a client or brand for if a 1099 never showed up. It's an easy first purchase, and it often leads to an engagement for the return itself.
Tips. Many people learned from your free "1099 season" thread or your deduction myth-busting videos and don't need a full answer. Tips let them send a one-time thank-you with nothing for you to deliver.
What should a follower send you, and what should they never send?
So orders arrive complete, put this in the "what you need" field on Custom Work. On a Paid Question, say it in your offer text.
For a Paid Question, they type it all: filing status, state, approximate figures, the forms they received (1099-NEC, 1099-K, 1099-MISC, W-2, K-1), and the actual question. If your answer depends on reading a document line by line, it's Custom Work, not a question.
For Custom Work, they write a brief and can attach up to 5 files: a P&L or bank-category export, last year's return pages, the 1099s in question, a payroll summary. Tell them which five to pick. "Year-to-date P&L, last year's 1040 pages 1β2, Schedule C, and up to two 1099s" is clearer than "send your documents."
What they should never send: never ask for full SSNs. Say it in your offer text and listings, and have them black out Social Security numbers, ITINs, bank account and routing numbers, and dates of birth before uploading. You can answer a planning question without any of them, and many 1099s already mask the recipient number. Don't ask for logins to bank, payroll or platform accounts either. An export or screenshot is enough for anything that fits in one order.
How long should you take to reply in filing season?
You choose the reply or delivery time for each offer, from 1β24 hours or 1β5 days. Five days is the maximum. Tax work is seasonal, so set it by season:
- Late January to April 15: 3β5 days on Paid Questions and planning notes, so orders fit around returns instead of competing with them.
- May to August: 24β48 hours. This is when you can be the fast answer.
- The week before September 15, January 15 and October 15: keep your window, and add an "order by" date to your planning note listing so nobody expects a Q3 number after the payment is due.
You can change these windows whenever you like. In a Paid Question, each follow-up is answered within 24 hours, so in peak weeks keep your first answer complete enough that follow-ups stay short.
Large jobs don't fit in a single order, because orders have no milestones and no built-in revision rounds. Multi-year unfiled returns, an amended return, or a full bookkeeping cleanup belong in your engagement. On Brillay, sell a clearly scoped piece instead: "review one year's 1099s against your income records" or "a written catch-up plan for unfiled years, listing what to gather first." Say plainly in the listing that the work itself is a separate engagement.
You also write your own correction and refund policies, and followers see them before paying. A tax example: "If a corrected 1099 arrives after I deliver your note, message me on the order and I'll update the numbers once." For Custom Work, the follower gets a support conversation on the order after delivery, so that's where it happens.
How much should you charge for a tax question or a planning note?
You set the price. Common starting points for preparers selling to freelancers and small businesses:
- One tax question answered: $40β$90, toward the higher end if you're an EA or CPA or the question involves an entity.
- Document checklist: $35β$75.
- Quarterly planning note: $125β$250, depending on how many income sources they have.
- S-corp quarterly planning: $200β$400 for one quarter or one election decision.
Check each price against your hourly rate. A written answer that takes you 15 minutes of thinking and 10 of writing should earn at least what that half hour earns on a return, plus something for the fact that you put it in writing. Many preparers raise question prices from February through April and lower them in summer, when they want the volume. Nothing here is an income promise. What you earn depends on your audience, your prices and how many people order.
Cost on the Brillay side is simple. No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. For a seasonal practice, that means the page costs nothing to keep up in the months when nobody is asking. The pricing page has the full breakdown.
Where does general tax information end and preparing their return begin?
This decides how you write every offer and every answer.
A Paid Question is general tax information unless you've been engaged as their preparer. Explain how the rule generally works for someone in that position. A note that calculates a payment, or tells someone what to file or pay based on their own figures or documents, is no longer general information, so it runs as a limited-scope engagement under your own terms and your credential's written-advice rules. Put the general-information sentence in your Paid Question offer text and at the end of each general answer; numbers-based notes carry your limited-scope terms instead. Either way, you're working only from what the follower told you, so say so: "Based on what you told me, here's how this generally worksβ¦" on a Paid Question, and "Based on the figures you gave meβ¦" on a planning note.
Don't prepare, sign or file a return through a Brillay order. Return preparation stays in your own engagement letter, your own software and your own e-file process, with your PTIN where it belongs. If someone sends a Paid Question that boils down to "can you just do my taxes," answer it by telling them how to engage you for the return.
No guaranteed refunds. Never promise a refund amount, that a deduction will hold up if examined, or that a penalty will be abated. Phrase it as "here's how this generally works" and "here's what I'd want to see before saying more."
Your credential's own rules still apply to written answers. That means Circular 230 for anyone who practices before the IRS, and your state board for CPAs. If you're unsure whether a type of answer fits within them, keep that type out of your offers.
What's different for CPAs and enrolled agents who also cover financial statements and planning?
If you're a CPA or enrolled agent whose work goes beyond the return, your buyers and questions shift. Buyers are more often owners of established small businesses who run monthly financials in QuickBooks or Xero, or creators who have just formed an LLC and suddenly have a balance sheet.
Their questions are about statements and planning rather than single forms. "Why does my P&L show a profit when the bank account is empty?" "Should we be on cash or accrual?" "My owner draws are showing up as expenses. Is that wrong?" "If I buy the new camera rig before December 31, what does that do to this year's tax?"
Offers that fit:
- Financial statement read-through (Custom Work). They send a P&L and balance sheet export, plus the general ledger detail for one account if needed. You deliver a written note flagging the three to five issues that matter most and what to fix first.
- Year-end tax planning note (Custom Work). Sell it October through December from a year-to-date P&L. It covers timing of equipment purchases, retirement plan options for the self-employed, and the estimated-tax position going into January.
- IRS notice explainer (Paid Question). This suits enrolled agents especially. The follower types what the notice says, such as a CP2000 or CP14, and you explain in general terms what it means and what the response usually involves. Representation stays in your engagement.
The care wording is the same: general tax information unless you've been engaged, never full SSNs, no guaranteed refunds or outcomes. The read-through and the year-end note work from the business's own figures, so sell them as limited-scope engagements under your own terms, like the quarterly planning note. One extra point: if you perform attest work (audits, reviews or compilations) for a business, check your independence rules before selling that client anything else.
How do followers and existing clients actually pay?
Today most preparers handle stray questions in one of three ways: answer for free, book an hourly call that's far more time than a five-minute question needs, or send an invoice and wait. Brillay replaces that with one link you put in your bio, your email signature, and your in-season autoresponder.
The follower opens your page, reads the offer, and pays upfront by card as a guest, with no account to create. They see the public name you choose, such as "Harbor Street Tax," on your page, at checkout and on their card statement. Your legal name goes only to Stripe for identity verification and payouts. Their question or brief comes in already paid, and you answer in writing on your own time, with no live call and nothing to schedule. How it works walks through the follower's side step by step.
How do you set this up before the next deadline?
- Choose two offers. One tax question answered plus a quarterly planning note covers most freelancer and creator demand.
- Write each Custom Work listing in three parts: what's included, what you need (with the black-out line) and what's excluded (no return preparation, no representation, no guaranteed refunds). On your Paid Question, cover the same points in the offer text. On the planning note, add your limited-scope terms.
- Set reply windows for the season you're in, and add a calendar reminder to change them on April 16.
- Write your correction and refund policies in your own words.
- Put the link where the questions arrive: pinned under your "quarterly taxes for creators" video, in your bio, and in the autoresponder clients get when they email in March.
You can be live today, before you've written a single answer. Create your Brillay page and send the link with the next "quick question" that lands.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sell one-off tax answers without taking the person on as a client?
Yes, within limits. A Paid Question is one private question with a written answer and up to two follow-ups. Without an engagement, explain how the rule generally works for someone in that position and make clear that preparing their return is separate. If you want to tell them what to file or pay, sell that as a Custom Work note under your limited-scope terms instead.
How do I charge existing clients for out-of-scope questions?
Add a line to your engagement letter saying questions outside the return are billed separately, then send your Paid Question link when one comes in. The client pays upfront and gets a written answer inside your reply window, and you never have to write a one-line invoice.
How should I price quarterly S-corp tax planning?
Price it as a scoped Custom Work order for one quarter or one decision, under your limited-scope terms, not as an open-ended retainer. A common starting point is $200β$400, depending on payroll complexity and how clean their books are. If they want it every quarter, they order again each quarter.
What does Brillay cost a tax preparer?
There's no subscription. A small platform fee applies only to orders that are actually paid, and card processing is separate, as listed in the pricing section above. In your slow months the page costs you nothing.
Can a follower upload their 1099s with a Paid Question?
No. Paid Questions are text only, so the follower types the figures. If you need to see the forms, use a Custom Work offer, where they can attach up to 5 files with identifying numbers blacked out.
What if someone asks how big their refund will be?
Explain how the items they mentioned generally affect what they owe or get back, and say plainly that you're not promising a number: general tax information, no guaranteed refunds. If they want an actual figure, that comes from preparing the return, which is your engagement.
Explore more