A tip is money a follower gives with no deliverable owed; a donation implies charitable giving and possible tax-deduction expectations; a paid request purchases a defined reply, video, or service that the creator must deliver. The right label depends on the promise: nothing back, support for a qualified charity, or a specific outcome. Tips let followers send a one-time thank-you, with nothing for you to deliver and no membership for them to join.
Choosing an inaccurate label can create mismatched expectations. The IRS's gig economy guidance treats payments creators receive for their work — including tips and support payments — as taxable self-employment income regardless of what the payment button is called, and sets $400 in net earnings as the point at which a return must be filed, not the point at which the money first becomes taxable (IRS, Manage taxes for your gig work); the IRS separately confirms that a contribution is deductible only when made to a qualified organization it recognizes as tax-exempt — not to an individual creator, no matter what the payment is labeled. Calling a paid deliverable a “tip” leaves supporters unsure whether you owe them anything. For a complete setup walkthrough, see the tips pillar guide.
Which label fits: quick answer
Use “tip” when nothing is owed back, “paid request” when the supporter is buying a specific reply, video, or service at a stated price and delivery time, and “donation” only when a qualified tax-exempt organization — not you — receives and administers the funds. Money a supporter sends to you personally is taxable self-employment income under either creator label.
The IRS sets $400 in net earnings from self-employment as the point at which a return must be filed; smaller amounts of supporter income remain taxable and reportable, because $400 is a filing trigger rather than a tax-free allowance.
| Payment type | Use this label when… | Cited basis |
|---|---|---|
| Tip | The supporter owes nothing back; you're accepting appreciation for content already delivered | The IRS's official list of occupations that customarily and regularly received tips names “Digital content creators” — streamer, online video creator, social media influencer, podcaster — at tipped-occupation code 210 (IRS, Occupations that customarily and regularly received tips on or before Dec. 31, 2024); the payment is taxable self-employment income at any size, with $400 in net earnings the point at which a return must be filed |
| Donation | Never for money a supporter sends to you personally — only when a qualified tax-exempt organization is itself receiving and administering the funds, verifiable in IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search | IRS Publication 526 states that “you can't deduct contributions to specific individuals” (IRS Publication 526, Charitable Contributions), and beginning with tax year 2026 a non-itemizer may deduct only up to $1,000 in cash contributions ($2,000 filing jointly) to certain qualified charities |
| Paid request | The supporter is buying a specific reply, video, or service at a set price and delivery time | Brillay's published how-it-works page states that paid-request delivery time is capped at up to 5 days and that creators can decline or refund what they cannot fulfill (how Brillay works); Cameo's Terms of Service give talent “up to seven days or longer” to fulfill or decline a booked request (Cameo Terms of Service) |
What is a tip?
A tip is a support payment a supporter sends with no promised deliverable attached. The supporter picks a set or suggested amount because they appreciate work you already published — not because you agreed to provide a reply, video, service, or any other outcome on a deadline. Nothing is owed back, and no delivery time clock starts.
On Brillay, Tips are one-time support payments with nothing to deliver, and supporters need no account to send one. You may still thank the supporter, but that acknowledgment is optional rather than part of the purchase.
Tips work well when:
- You want a low-friction way for supporters to support you without creating an ongoing obligation.
- Supporters want to show appreciation after enjoying your content rather than buy something specific.
- You do not want to manage delivery deadlines or revision requests for every payment.
If you are unsure what to suggest, start with familiar amounts such as $3, $5, or $10, let supporters choose a custom amount, and make clear that support is appreciated but optional. They can supplement creator income, but they do not promise recurring revenue — a dynamic that also shapes how street performers collect cashless tips now that cash-in-a-hat is no longer the default.
Tip products also carry published take rates a creator can compare before picking the label: YouTube pays creators 70% of Super Thanks revenue recognized by Google, calculated after local sales tax and App Store fees (YouTube Help, Super Thanks), while Buy Me a Coffee charges a 5% platform fee so the creator keeps 95% of each supporter payment, with Stripe card processing of roughly 2.9% + 30¢ handled separately (Buy Me a Coffee Help Center). Tips are one-time and sit on the same link as priced requests, and payouts go through your own connected Stripe account to your own bank.
For an independent creator, a supporter tip is self-employment income, not wage-based tip income, and it is taxable from the first dollar: the IRS sets $400 in net earnings from gig work as the point at which a return must be filed, and the source or label of the payment does not change either fact. The IRS list of occupations that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024 includes “Digital content creators,” defined as streamer, online video creator, social media influencer, and podcaster, at tipped-occupation code 210. The resulting deduction for qualified tips is capped at $25,000 a year and phases out once modified adjusted gross income exceeds $150,000, or $300,000 for joint filers (IRS, What the no tax on tips deduction means for you). IRS Notice 2025-69 limits that deduction to an amount “paid voluntarily without any consequence in the event of nonpayment,” that “is not the subject of negotiation, and is determined by the payor” (IRS Notice 2025-69) — the precise line that separates a tip from a priced paid request. Creators should ask a qualified tax professional how these rules apply to their business and records.
What is a donation?
A donation is money given for a charitable purpose, and the word implies two things: that the recipient is a qualified tax-exempt organization, and that the giver may be eligible for a deduction. Most individual creators meet neither condition, so “donation” advertises a legal status they do not hold rather than the payment they are actually taking.
IRS Publication 526 states plainly that “you can't deduct contributions to specific individuals,” and that deductible charitable contributions must go to a qualified organization the IRS recognizes. Beginning with tax year 2026, a taxpayer who does not itemize may deduct up to $1,000 of cash contributions, or $2,000 filing jointly, to certain qualified charities — a benefit that never extends to money sent to an individual creator (IRS Topic no. 506). GoFundMe draws the same line on its own platform: donations made to a personal GoFundMe fundraiser are “generally considered to be personal gifts” and “aren't guaranteed to be tax-deductible”. Money a supporter sends directly to an individual creator therefore does not become a deductible charitable contribution merely because the payment button says “donate.”
Calling ordinary creator support a donation also carries regulatory weight: the IRS's own guidance on charitable solicitation states that roughly 40 states require an organization to register with a state agency before soliciting residents for contributions, obligations built for registered charities, not individual creators. Unless you operate through an eligible organization and understand the applicable requirements, “tip” or “support” is usually a more accurate label.
This is general wording guidance, not financial or legal advice. Ask an accountant or attorney how payments should be characterized for your specific business and jurisdiction.
What is a paid request?
A paid request is a purchase with a defined deliverable attached. The supporter is buying a specific reply, video, review, or service at your set price, and you promise to deliver it within the time you chose. Delivery is owed, and a decline or refund is the fallback.
On Brillay, paid requests can include:
- Paid Questions: Paid Questions let a follower pay upfront to ask one private question, and you send one written reply on your own time — no live call or scheduling.
- Personalized Videos: Personalized Videos let a follower pay upfront for one personalized video for themselves or someone they care about: you set the price and the delivery time, then record it on your schedule.
- Custom Work: Custom Work lets you offer clearly scoped commissions and services: you set the price, the scope and the delivery time, and followers submit a brief and pay before you start.
Because a deliverable is owed, a paid request needs a price, a clear scope, and a delivery time window. For Paid Questions and Personalized Videos, followers pay upfront, you deliver accepted requests within the time you set, up to 5 days, and declined requests close and followers keep their money.
Named delivery time windows are standard for this offer type across the market: Cameo's Terms of Service give the talent “up to seven days or longer (at our sole discretion) to fulfill or decline” a booked request, while Brillay's published how-it-works page states a 5-day cap on paid-request delivery time. Because the amount is set against a deliverable rather than given freely, a paid request also cannot be a “qualified tip” under IRS Notice 2025-69, which requires the amount be paid voluntarily, not be the subject of negotiation, and be determined by the payor. Your page, your price, no application and no follower minimum.
That structure gives both sides clearer boundaries: the supporter knows what to expect and when, while the creator knows exactly what they agreed to deliver.
How does a Goal differ?
A Goal sits between a tip and a paid request: supporters contribute cash toward one named creator goal and watch a funding total move, but no individual contributor is owed a deliverable in return. It is not an Amazon-style product registry, and it is not a charitable donation simply because the money funds a stated goal. A Goal gives you money rather than a preselected item or parcel, so you can spend it on what the project actually needs.
A Goal is closest to a tip in that no individual contributor is owed a deliverable, but the payment supports a stated project or goal rather than representing open-ended appreciation. On Brillay, a Goal can show exact progress, a percentage, or no public progress figure.
Which payment model should you offer?
The right model depends entirely on what, if anything, the supporter is promised in return. Offer tips when nothing is owed back, offer paid requests when a specific reply, video, or service is owed at a set price and delivery time, and reserve “donation” for money a qualified tax-exempt organization actually receives and administers (IRS Topic no. 506).
| Comparison | Tips | Donations as a label | Paid requests |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is owed back? | Nothing | Depends on the framing and may imply charitable use | A specific reply, video, or service |
| What wording fits? | “Tip” or “support” | Use only when the charitable context is accurate | Name the deliverable, such as “paid question,” “shoutout,” or “service” |
| What structure is needed? | No deliverable or delivery time commitment | Legal and tax clarity about status and deductibility | Price, scope, delivery time, and decline or refund terms |
| Which Brillay feature applies? | Tips | Brillay has no charitable-donation product; ordinary creator support runs through Tips or Goals | Paid Questions, Personalized Videos, or Custom Work |
For tax purposes, the IRS says contributions made directly to specific individuals are not deductible charitable contributions (IRS Topic no. 506). For Brillay's own delivery rules, its published how-it-works page states that paid-request delivery time is capped at up to 5 days.
Form filing works the same way no matter which label a creator uses: when a payment platform functions as a third-party settlement organization, it must issue that creator a Form 1099-K once it processes more than $20,000 in gross payments and more than 200 transactions for them in a calendar year (IRS, Form 1099-K threshold FAQs). Income below that threshold is still taxable and reportable by the creator — the 1099-K is a platform filing trigger, not the line at which tips or paid-request income becomes taxable.
Creators do not have to choose only one model. Tips and paid requests can work side by side because they solve different supporter needs:
- Tips let supporters provide casual support without asking for anything back.
- Paid requests let supporters purchase a specific outcome under defined terms.
- Goals let supporters contribute toward a visible creator goal without receiving an individual deliverable.
“Donation” is usually not a separate creator offer; it is a label that should be reserved for an accurate charitable context. If nothing is owed back, call the payment a tip or support. If the supporter is buying a specific outcome, call it a paid request and name that outcome.
If you are deciding whether tips are enough or whether to add a recurring option, see tips without starting a membership. If you are unsure whether tips make sense for your audience size, small creators and tips explains why Brillay has no follower minimum (pricing).
Frequently asked questions
Are supporter tips taxable even when giving is optional?
Yes. The IRS treats supporter tips as taxable self-employment income at any amount, and sets $400 in net earnings from that work as the point at which a return must be filed — a filing trigger, not a tax-free allowance. Calling creator income a “tip,” “support payment,” or “donation” does not by itself remove tax obligations. Consult an accountant about reporting requirements for your situation.
Can a supporter deduct a donation made directly to a creator?
No, not merely because it is labeled a donation. The IRS says contributions to specific individuals are not deductible and that deductible charitable contributions generally must be made to qualified organizations (IRS Topic no. 506).
What is the clearest difference between a tip and a paid request?
The difference is the creator’s obligation. A tip requires no reply, deliverable, or deadline. A paid request creates an obligation to provide a defined reply, video, or service within the stated delivery time. If nothing is owed, call it a tip; if something specific is owed, name the deliverable.
Can a creator claim the “no tax on tips” deduction on supporter tips?
Possibly, but only on amounts that meet the statutory test. The IRS list of occupations that customarily and regularly received tips on or before December 31, 2024 includes “Digital content creators” — streamer, online video creator, social media influencer, podcaster — at tipped-occupation code 210. The deduction is capped at $25,000 a year and phases out above $150,000 of modified adjusted gross income, or $300,000 for joint filers (IRS). The payment must still be a qualified tip under IRS Notice 2025-69: paid voluntarily, not the subject of negotiation, and determined by the payor. Confirm with a tax professional before claiming it.
Should an individual creator use the word “donation”?
Generally, no. “Donation” can imply charitable status and tax deductibility, but the IRS says payments to specific individuals are not deductible charitable contributions. “Tip” or “support” is usually more accurate unless the payment is being collected by a qualified charitable organization.
How can you offer tips and paid requests together?
You run both on one link: a tip button for supporters who only want to say thanks, and separately priced paid requests for anything with a real deliverable. Brillay puts Tips, Paid Questions, Personalized Videos, Custom Work, and Goals on one creator page, so supporters can choose what they want before paying. Whichever tool you use, label each offer by what it actually promises. Create your free Brillay page when you want tips and paid requests side by side.
Keep reading
New in the library
Ready to get paid for the interactions you already get?
Create your free Brillay link