An email problem usually arrives as something the client can paste: a DMARC record, the Authentication-Results line from a test send, a screenshot of a Klaviyo flow canvas, a cold sequence nobody replies to. Email marketing consultants get paid for it online by pricing the read of that material: a written answer when one record or one number is enough, a scoped flow audit or deliverability fix when you need to see every flow and 90 days of metrics. On Brillay the client pastes the record into a Paid Question, or attaches the screenshots to a Custom Work order, and pays before you look at any of it; you send back the exact DNS records to add or a prioritized fix list.
This is for people who work inside email platforms (Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Omnisend, Substack, beehiiv, Instantly, Smartlead) on lists, flows and inbox placement. If your paid advice is mostly search rankings and site traffic, the marketing consultants page fits you better.
What do clients actually ask an email marketing consultant for?
The requests repeat, and you have probably answered most of them for free already:
- "Can you look at our flows?" A Shopify store owner has a welcome series, an abandoned checkout flow and a post-purchase email that someone set up two years ago and nobody has touched since.
- "Our open rate fell by more than half." Sometimes it's a real deliverability problem. Sometimes the old number was inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection and the new one is closer to the truth.
- "Gmail is sending us to spam." Often this traces back to the bulk-sender rules: SPF and DKIM in place, a DMARC record that aligns, one-click unsubscribe, and spam complaints kept to a few per thousand emails at most.
- "Can you write our welcome sequence?" A creator or store collects emails with a lead magnet or a first-order discount, then sends one forgettable email and goes quiet.
- "Why does nobody reply to our cold emails?" An agency or SaaS founder has a sequence, a few sending domains and a list, and almost no replies.
- "How do I get free subscribers to go paid?" A newsletter writer on Substack or beehiiv with a growing list and almost no paid conversions.
The common thread: the buyer can send nearly everything you need without a call. Flow builder screenshots, 30- or 90-day flow metrics, the email copy itself, DNS records (which are plain text), a Google Postmaster Tools screenshot, the last few campaign results. That's why this work sells well as written, asynchronous (no live call) delivery.
Which email services should you sell first?
Start with two or three offers, each scoped so it fits in one order. These four cover most of what email consultants get asked.
1. Email account audit or Klaviyo flow audit (Custom Work). What's included: a review of the core flows (welcome, abandoned checkout, browse abandonment, post-purchase, winback, sunset), their timing, filters and exit conditions, the split between flow and campaign revenue, signup forms, and a prioritized fix list. What the client sends: the platform, a screenshot of each flow canvas, the flow metrics (open rate, click rate, placed order rate, revenue per recipient), the signup form and the list size. A Custom Work brief takes up to 5 files, so ask them to combine screenshots into one or two PDFs. Delivery: 3β5 days. What you send back: a written note with the top fixes, plus an annotated PDF, a screen-recorded walkthrough (a video in a delivery can run up to 20 minutes) or a link to a doc.
2. Welcome sequence draft (Custom Work). What's included: three to five emails with subject lines, preview text, send timing, and where the discount or lead magnet appears. What the client sends: what they sell, who signs up and why, the current welcome email, two or three emails whose voice they like, and the offer. Delivery: 3β5 days. What you send back: a doc with emails ready to paste into their platform. Say clearly whether you also build the flow or only write it.
3. Deliverability check with fixes (Custom Work). What's included: SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the sending domain, alignment with their email platform, the exact records to add or change, and short notes on warm-up and list hygiene. What the client sends: the sending domain, the platform, a screenshot of their DNS settings, Postmaster Tools if they have it, and recent bounce and complaint numbers. Delivery: 1β2 days, because nobody with a spam problem wants to wait a week.
4. One written answer (Paid Questions). For the single question that doesn't need an audit. The follower writes it out and can paste in a DMARC record, a subject line or a few numbers; you reply in writing inside the window you set, and they can ask up to two follow-ups. It suits questions like "is p=none enough for now?", "should we send from a subdomain?" or "is our open rate bad for a 40,000-person list?" When the honest answer is "I'd need to see the flows," point them to the audit.
What should your listing say so the brief arrives complete?
A Custom Work listing has a title, a description, what the follower gets, what you need from them, what's excluded, and a delivery time. Write the "what I need" field like a checklist, because a vague brief is what turns a 3-day audit into a week of back-and-forth. For a flow audit:
- What you get: written review of up to 5 flows, prioritized fix list, annotated screenshots.
- What I need: platform name; screenshots of each flow canvas; 90-day flow metrics; signup form screenshot; list size; your average order value.
- Not included: building or editing flows inside your account, campaign calendars, ongoing management.
Ask for screenshots, not logins. Credentials add risk for both sides and pull the job past what one order covers. If you also do builds, sell that as a separate listing and agree on access before you start.
You also write three short policies that the client sees before paying: a Support policy, a Correction & revision policy and a Refund policy. After you deliver Custom Work, the client gets a support conversation on the same order where they can ask about the delivery, report a broken link or request a correction. There are no built-in revision rounds, so your Correction & revision policy is where you say what you'll fix, for example: "I'll correct anything I got factually wrong about your setup; new flows or extra emails are a new order." For more on structuring audits this way, see selling a marketing audit as an async service.
How long should an email audit take, and what about full Klaviyo builds?
You choose a delivery time from 1β24 hours or 1β5 days, and five days is the maximum. There are no milestones, so a full account build (eight flows, forms, segments, templates and a campaign plan) doesn't fit in one order. Sell a piece that does:
- "Welcome series build: one flow, four emails, written and mapped"
- "Abandoned checkout flow: two emails plus timing and filters"
- "Black Friday prep: segment plan and three campaign drafts"
A client who likes the first piece orders the next one. The same goes for deliverability. Fixing the DNS records fits in a day. A four-week warm-up of a new domain doesn't, so sell the warm-up plan: a written schedule of daily volumes and which segments to send to first, which they follow themselves.
How should you price a flow audit, a welcome sequence or a DMARC fix?
You set the price. Some common starting points to compare against your own experience (these are not earnings estimates):
- Paid Question: around $25β50 for one written answer with up to two follow-ups.
- Deliverability check with fixes: around $75β150, more if you offer 24-hour delivery.
- Flow audit: around $100β250 for three to five flows. A focused audit near $100 is a common place to start.
- Welcome sequence draft: around $150β400 depending on the number of emails and how much research the brand needs.
Price on what drives the effort: how many flows or emails, how much data you have to read, the platform, and how fast they want it. Speed is worth charging for, because a store that's in spam the week before a launch values a 24-hour turnaround.
No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. The details are on the pricing page.
What should you refuse to work on?
Put this in your listing and in your answers: No purchased lists; anti-spam and consent rules apply. You don't build sends to scraped or bought lists, you don't help anyone get around spam filters, and the client's sending has to follow the consent and unsubscribe rules where their subscribers live, such as CAN-SPAM in the US, GDPR in the EU and CASL in Canada.
Be equally plain about results. Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook decide inbox placement, and readers decide whether to open and click. You can fix authentication, cut unengaged subscribers and rewrite the copy; you can't promise an open rate, inbox placement or revenue. Write "recommendations, not guaranteed results" into the listing so nobody pays expecting a number.
Klaviyo experts: what's different for Shopify and DTC flows?
Your buyers are Shopify and DTC store owners and their small marketing teams. They think in revenue, so the requests sound like "our flows barely earn anything next to our campaigns" or "abandoned checkout converts worse than last year."
What changes:
- The inputs are Klaviyo-specific. Ask for flow analytics with placed order rate and revenue per recipient, the flow filters (people often forget "has not placed order since starting this flow"), and whether SMS runs in the same flows. SMS consent is separate from email consent, so flag it if they mix the two.
- The offers: a Klaviyo flow audit and a welcome series build. Scope the build as one flow per order: the flow map, the emails and the timing. If you build it inside their account, they add you as a user on their side, and you agree beforehand that the job covers that one flow.
- Attribution is a trap. Klaviyo's attributed revenue depends on the attribution window, so treat "this flow will make $X" as a forecast in your notes, never a promise.
- Seasonality matters. Q4 prep (segments of people engaged in the last 90 days, list cleaning before Black Friday) is a natural one-order offer to publish in September.
Same care rule: no purchased lists, and consent rules apply to every flow you touch.
Deliverability consultants: what's different when emails land in spam?
Your buyers are anyone whose open rate fell off a cliff: a creator after a big list import, a store after switching platforms, a SaaS company after moving to a new domain. They usually message you in a panic, so speed and clear instructions matter more here than anywhere else.
What changes:
- The best inputs are text. DNS records, and the "Authentication-Results" line from the header of an email they sent to themselves, can be pasted straight into a Paid Question. That makes "why are my emails going to spam?" a good written question at a lower price.
- The usual fixes are specific. A domain with two SPF records (only one is allowed), an SPF record over the 10-lookup limit, missing DKIM records from the email platform, or a DMARC record that doesn't exist or doesn't align. You write out the exact records to add.
- The DMARC path: start at p=none with aggregate reports (rua) going somewhere they'll read, then move to quarantine once legitimate senders all pass.
- Beyond DNS: a sending subdomain, a warm-up schedule, and a sunset flow that stops mailing people who haven't opened in months.
- The offers: an SPF, DKIM and DMARC check with fixes as Custom Work, and an answer on why emails land in spam as a Paid Question.
The care rule applies here most of all: no purchased lists; anti-spam and consent rules apply. A bought list is one of the fastest ways into the spam folder, so say so before you take the job, and be clear that the mailbox providers make the final call.
Cold email consultants: what's different for B2B outbound?
Your buyers are agencies, SaaS founders, recruiters and consultants doing outbound. They aren't emailing subscribers; they're emailing prospects who never signed up, which changes both the work and the care wording.
What changes:
- The inputs: the sequence copy (usually three or four steps), the ideal customer profile, the offer, where the list came from, the reply and positive-reply numbers, and the sending setup: secondary domains, mailboxes per domain, daily volume per mailbox, and the sending tool.
- The offers: a cold email sequence rewrite (new first lines, a shorter ask, follow-ups that add something instead of "bumping this up"), and an offer and targeting review, because a weak offer sent to the wrong role fails no matter how good the copy is.
- Infrastructure questions fit Paid Questions well: "how many mailboxes per domain?", "do I need a custom tracking domain?", "should I turn off open tracking?"
Care wording for this part: Follow anti-spam rules; no guaranteed replies. Every email needs a real sender, a working opt-out and an honest subject line, and the rules on contacting businesses differ by country. You rewrite the sequence; the prospects decide whether to reply. There's more on packaging this in how to sell cold email and pitch reviews.
Substack growth coaches: what's different for newsletter writers?
Your buyers are newsletter writers on Substack and beehiiv, often solo, often with fewer than a few thousand subscribers and a tight budget. They ask about growth and paid conversion, not flows or revenue per recipient.
What changes:
- The inputs: the publication link, subscriber count, open rate, free-to-paid conversion, the welcome email text, and the about page. Most of this is public or easy to paste.
- The offers: a newsletter audit (name and positioning, about page, welcome email, posting cadence, how they use recommendations or Boosts) and a welcome email and paywall review: where the paywall cuts the post, what paid subscribers get, and whether the upgrade ask makes sense.
- Lower prices, more volume. A Paid Question at the lower end of your range often fits these writers better than a full audit, and many order the audit later.
- Not every writer needs paid subscriptions. Some earn more from other income than from a paywall; the guide to making money on Substack without paid subscriptions covers those options.
Care wording for this part: No guaranteed subscriber growth. You can fix the welcome email and the paywall; you can't promise a subscriber count.
Why sell fixed-scope work instead of a discovery call and an invoice?
The usual route goes: a free discovery call, a proposal, an invoice, a reminder, maybe a payment, then a request for screenshots you should have had on day one. That works for retainers. It costs too much time for a $100 audit or a $35 answer.
With a published listing, the price, scope and delivery time are decided once. The client submits the brief, attaches the files and pays upfront in the same checkout, so what reaches you is a job you can start, not a lead to chase. They pay on your own page, not on a marketplace that shows them other consultants first. There's no follower minimum and nothing to apply for: if your list is 300 readers who like your teardowns, the first of them can order today.
Can your own newsletter readers and brands pay you too?
Most email consultants publish something themselves: a newsletter of flow teardowns, deliverability tips or swipe files. That audience can support you in two lighter ways:
- Tips: a one-time thank-you link at the bottom of a free teardown, with nothing for you to deliver and no membership for anyone to join.
- Goals: one named goal with a progress bar, such as "a year of seed-list testing for public deliverability tests." Readers make one-time contributions, every contribution is yours whether or not you reach the goal, there's no deadline unless you set one, and there's nothing to ship.
Email platforms and tools often sponsor people who teach email. Brand Collaboration Inquiries adds a Work with Me form that collects a brand's budget, timeline and deliverables into a separate brand inbox, so sponsor requests don't get mixed up with client briefs.
Followers see the public name you choose, which can be your agency or newsletter name, not your legal name. Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and followers pay by card from anywhere.
How do you start?
- Create your page and set your public name, whether that's your own name or your studio's.
- Add one Custom Work listing: a flow audit or a deliverability check, with the "what I need" checklist and the exclusions written out. See how Custom Work listings are set up.
- Turn on Paid Questions with a reply time you can keep, such as 24 hours.
- Write your Support, Correction & revision and Refund policies in a few sentences each.
- Put the link where the questions already come in: your bio, your email signature, the footer of your newsletter, and the end of every free teardown you post.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sell a full email marketing setup in one order?
Not as one big project. Delivery is capped at five days and there are no milestones, so split the setup into pieces that each fit one order: the welcome series, then abandoned checkout, then post-purchase. Each piece is useful on its own, and the client can order the next one when they're ready.
What does it cost an email consultant to use Brillay?
There's no monthly fee and no plan to upgrade to. You pay the platform fee described in the pricing section above only when a client actually pays you, and card processing is separate.
Can I promise better open rates or inbox placement?
No. Mailbox providers decide placement, and Apple Mail Privacy Protection makes open rates unreliable anyway. Promise the work instead: the records you'll fix, the flows you'll review, the emails you'll write. And keep the rule in every listing: no purchased lists; anti-spam and consent rules apply.
Does the client need an account to pay me?
No. The client pays by card as a guest on your page, attaches their brief and files at checkout, and gets your delivery and any support conversation through the same order link.
What if the client wants changes after I deliver the audit?
After a Custom Work delivery, the client can open a support conversation on the order to ask a question, report a broken file or link, or request a correction. Your Correction & revision policy, which they saw before paying, sets out what you'll fix as part of the order and what counts as new work.
Explore more