Get paid for the questions and custom requests you already get from followers.

Create your free Brillay link

For creators

Songwriting coach? Get paid for lyric notes and demo critiques

Sell lyric questions and demo critiques from your bio: writers paste a lyric or attach a voice memo, pay upfront, and you reply in writing on your own time.

Updated November 2026

Get paid for this — with Brillay

Three writers under your 400-view prosody breakdown asking 'can you look at mine?': why give them free reads while you wait to be big enough to charge, when a paid lyric question works from your very first follower?

Brillay is a link in your bio where followers pay you directly for:

Paid QuestionsCustom WorkTipsPersonalized VideosGoals

A writer from a co-writing circle taps your bio inside TikTok, pastes a chorus with the title buried in line three, and pays by card as a guest right there; you answer it after tomorrow's lesson.

No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid.

When a writer asks whether their chorus is working, the useful answer is a few marked lines: where the title lands, which stressed syllables fall on weak beats, and whether verse two says anything new, and all of that fits in writing. Songwriting coaches get paid for it on Brillay in two ways: a single lyric question becomes a Paid Question, where the writer pastes the labeled lyric, pays upfront and gets your written notes back, while a full demo listen becomes Custom Work, with the phone voice memo and lyric sheet attached to the brief. You set the price and turnaround for each, and both sit on the link already in your bio.

What do aspiring songwriters actually send you?

If you coach songwriting, you know these messages already:

  • A full lyric pasted into a DM with no section labels and one line on top: “be honest, is this any good?”
  • A work tape: one take on a phone, acoustic guitar or piano, the vocal half-buried, and an apology for the sound before the song even starts.
  • “My chorus feels flat and I can’t tell why.”
  • “Does this song need a bridge, or am I just padding it?”
  • “I rhymed fire with desire. Is that too cheesy?”
  • “The words don’t fit the melody in verse two. I keep cramming syllables.”
  • “I want to pitch this. Is it ready?”

Look at what isn’t on that list. Nobody is asking about compression, vocal tone or why the low end is muddy. Your lane is the song itself: structure, hook and title placement, prosody (whether the stressed syllables land on the strong beats), rhyme choice and rhyme scheme, melodic contour, point of view, and whether each verse gives the listener something new. That lane is narrow and specific, and it’s why a written answer is a good fit.

Which song feedback should you sell first?

Start with two or three offers that match the requests you already get. These four cover most of them.

1. One lyric question (Paid Question). One specific question about one lyric, for example “does my verse two repeat verse one?” or “where should the title go?” The writer pastes the whole lyric with sections labeled and asks the question. You reply in writing with what’s working, what’s getting in the way (quote the lines), and two or three options to try. A short, focused reply is fine. A common starting point is $20–$35.

2. Notes to fix a weak chorus (Custom Work). The writer attaches the lyric and, if melody is part of the problem, the voice memo, plus a line about what the chorus should make the listener feel. This request is so common it deserves its own listing. Typical problems you diagnose: the title buried in line three, a chorus melody that never climbs above the verse, too many new ideas and no repetition, or a chorus that arrives after a full minute. You send back the marked-up chorus, a short written diagnosis and two or three rewrite directions. A common starting point is $30–$50.

3. Lyric and melody feedback on a demo (Custom Work). This is your core offer. The writer sends the voice memo, a lyric sheet, one reference song and what they want the song to do. You send back an annotated lyric sheet, written notes section by section, and, if you like, a short voice memo singing an alternate chorus line or melody shape. Delivery of three to five days is normal for this kind of work. Many coaches price one full song somewhere around $60–$100.

4. Song critique before pitching (Custom Work). The writer is about to send the song to an artist, a publisher, a sync library or a contest. You give a clear verdict (ready, one more rewrite, or park it), the three changes that matter most, and a pitch-readiness check. A common starting point is $90–$150, because the stakes for the writer are higher and your notes have to be sharper.

How does a lyric question work as a Paid Question?

A Paid Question is one private question, answered in writing. The follower pays upfront as a guest, you reply on your own time, and the thread stays private between the two of you. That matters to writers who don’t want an unreleased lyric posted in a public comment section. More about the format is on the Paid Questions page.

Paid Questions are text in both directions, so this offer is for lyric-level questions. In your description, tell writers exactly what to send:

  • The full lyric, pasted in, with sections labeled (Verse 1, Pre-chorus, Chorus, Bridge).
  • The genre and one artist they’d like it to sit next to.
  • One question. “Is the chorus doing its job?” is a good one. “Thoughts?” isn’t.
  • If melody is part of the problem, a plain description of it: “verse stays low and talky, chorus jumps up on the title.”

A useful reply usually has a shape like this. First, name what works, so they know what to keep (“the image of the porch light in verse one is doing all the heavy lifting”). Then point to the problem with line numbers (“line 3 of the chorus puts the stress on ‘to’ instead of ‘leave,’ so the hook word falls on a weak beat”). Then give options rather than one rewrite: move the title to the first line, swap the perfect rhyme for a slant rhyme, cut the chorus from six lines to four.

The writer can then ask up to two follow-ups, which suits songwriting well: “I moved the title up, does the new pre-chorus still lead into it?” You choose your reply time, from 1–24 hours or 1–5 days. Each follow-up is answered within 24 hours. If a writer clearly needs their melody heard, point them to your chorus notes or demo critique instead of trying to judge it from a description.

How do you scope a demo critique so it fits one order?

Custom Work is where the voice memo comes in. You publish a listing with a title, what the writer gets, what you need from them, what’s excluded, a price and a delivery time. The writer sends a brief and up to 5 files, and pays before you start. Details are on the Custom Work page.

A listing for a demo critique might read:

  • What you get: an annotated lyric sheet, written notes on structure, hook, prosody, rhyme and melody for each section, and a short voice memo of any alternate line or melody I suggest.
  • What I need: your demo as an audio file (a phone voice memo is fine), the lyric sheet, one reference song, and what you want this song to do (release it, pitch it, play it out).
  • Not included: mix or production notes, vocal technique coaching, rewriting the song for you, or co-writing.
  • Delivery: 4 days.

You deliver a written note plus up to 5 files and links: a PDF of the marked-up lyric, a voice memo singing the alternate chorus, and maybe a link to a song that shows the structure you’re describing. Audio or video in a delivery can be up to 20 minutes, which is more than enough for a walkthrough.

Keep each order to something you can finish within your window. The longest delivery time you can choose is five days. There are no milestones and no built-in revision rounds. So sell one song per order, not a whole EP or an eight-week song development program. A writer working on an EP buys one critique per song. A writer who rewrites after your notes buys a second pass as a new order. Say this plainly in the listing so nobody expects ongoing coaching from a single purchase.

For the “can you look again?” moment, you write your own correction and revision policy. Writers see it before they pay. After you deliver, the writer can contact you on the same order if a file won’t open or they have a question about your notes, and you decide how to handle it under the policy you published.

What should a pre-pitch critique promise, and what shouldn’t it?

Writers who are about to pitch want to know whether the song is ready. A good pre-pitch critique checks the things a busy listener notices first:

  • Does the first chorus arrive quickly, and is the title in it, clearly sung?
  • Can you sum up the song’s idea in one line from the title alone?
  • Does verse two add something new, or does it restate verse one in different words?
  • Is the demo clear enough that the lyric and melody come through, even if it’s just guitar and vocal?
  • Is the lyric sheet clean: sections labeled, no typos, the writer’s name on it?

Be equally clear about what a critique doesn’t buy. There are no guaranteed results: you can’t promise a cut, a sync placement, a publishing deal or a contest win, and your listing shouldn’t suggest otherwise. What you sell is an experienced ear and specific changes. Writers who understand that value it more, not less.

How much should you charge for lyric and demo feedback?

You set the price. A useful way to decide is to count your real time per order. A focused lyric question might take you ten to fifteen minutes. A full demo critique with several listens, an annotated lyric sheet and a recorded alternate melody can take an hour or more. Price each offer so you’re still glad to do it when the fifth one of the week comes in.

As common starting points: $20–$35 for a lyric question (Paid Question), $30–$50 for chorus fix notes (Custom Work), $60–$100 for a full lyric and melody critique of one song, and $90–$150 for a pre-pitch critique. If you also sell hourly coaching sessions, a written answer lets you offer a lower entry price to writers who would never book a full hour, without discounting your session rate. When orders pile up, raise the price or choose a longer reply time. Both are your call.

No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.

The full breakdown is on the pricing page. For a wider look at song feedback offers, including mix and master critiques that sit outside a songwriting coach’s lane, see Sell Song Feedback Online.

Why would a writer pay when critique groups are free?

Many of your buyers already belong to a co-writing circle or a free critique group, and those groups are worth a lot. But the writer who messages you usually wants something a group doesn’t give them:

  • One trusted voice. Ten peers give ten opinions, and half of them contradict each other. The writer picked you because they trust your ear.
  • No waiting for a turn. Groups work through songs in rounds. Your listing gives a delivery time.
  • Privacy. Some writers don’t want an unreleased lyric shared with a room or posted where anyone can copy the hook. A Paid Question thread and a Custom Work order stay between the two of you.
  • An answer to their actual question. Group feedback drifts toward taste. A paid question keeps your reply on the thing they asked.

So you’re not competing with the group. Your link is the next step after it, for the song a writer cares about most.

Where do tips, videos and goals fit for a songwriting coach?

Paid Questions and Custom Work will bring in most of your income. Three smaller pieces round out the page:

  • Tips. If you run live “send me your chorus” sessions or post free hook breakdowns, some viewers want to say thank you without ordering anything. A tip is a one-time thank-you, with nothing for you to deliver.
  • Personalized Videos. A short pep talk before a student’s first writers’ round or open mic, or a “you finished your first song” message ordered by a friend or parent as a gift. The follower pays upfront, and you set the price and delivery time.
  • Goals. Raising money for your own EP, a co-write trip, or a run of free songwriting workshops? A Goal shows one named target with a progress bar. Followers chip in one time, every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, there’s no deadline unless you set one, and there’s nothing to ship.

If you also teach voice, guitar or piano lessons alongside songwriting, the music teachers page covers the performance-feedback side.

How do you start taking paid song feedback this week?

  1. Create your page and choose the public name followers will see. That name appears on your page, at checkout and on their card statement. Your legal name goes only to Stripe for identity checks and payouts.
  2. Turn on Paid Questions, set a price and a reply time you can keep during a busy week, and say in the description that it's for one lyric question.
  3. Add two Custom Work listings, “Notes to fix a weak chorus” and “Lyric and melody feedback on one demo,” using the scope above, with clear exclusions.
  4. Write your support, correction and refund policies in two or three plain sentences each.
  5. Put the link in your bio. The next time someone sends “can you listen real quick?”, reply kindly with the link and a line about which offer fits their question.
  6. On TikTok or Instagram, post one before-and-after chorus fix (with the writer’s permission). It shows exactly what someone gets when they order from your link.

There’s no follower minimum and nothing to apply for, so your first order can come from a small account. Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and followers pay by card from anywhere. How it works walks through the follower’s side step by step. When you’re ready, start your Brillay page.

Frequently asked questions

Can a writer send a voice memo with a Paid Question?

No. Paid Questions are written in both directions, so they suit lyric questions where the writer pastes the words in. When you need to hear the melody, sell chorus notes or a demo critique as Custom Work. The writer attaches up to 5 files, such as the memo and the lyric sheet, along with their brief.

What does it cost me to use Brillay?

There’s no monthly fee. A small platform fee applies only when a follower actually pays you, at the rates in the pricing section above, and card processing is separate.

What if the writer disagrees with my notes or wants another look?

On a Paid Question, they have up to two follow-ups to push back or test a rewrite. On a Custom Work order, your published correction policy covers what you’ll fix, and a full second pass on a rewritten song is a new order.

Do my followers need to create an account to pay?

No. They pay by card as a guest, right from your link. They can do it straight from the TikTok or Instagram post where they found you.

How fast do I have to reply?

You choose. Reply and delivery times range from 1–24 hours or 1–5 days, and five days is the longest. Pick a window you can keep even when a stack of demos arrives after a viral post.

Can I coach a writer through a whole album this way?

Not as one order. Break it into pieces that each fit in five days, such as one song per critique or one chorus fix per order, and let the writer order the next piece when they’re ready.

Start getting paid for the questions and requests you already get

Create your free Brillay link. No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.

Create your free Brillay link