Trading card experts get paid online by charging for the call collectors make before every submission: will this card come back a 10 or a 9, and does that 9 sell for enough over raw to cover the grading fee, two-way shipping and months of waiting? A collector who already measured 55/45 and pulled their own comps can just type the numbers into a Brillay Paid Question; when the call depends on corners, edges and holo surface you have to see, it's a Custom Work grading check, at the price and delivery time you set. Either way, what you send back is written: a likely grade range and a grade-or-sell-raw verdict against recent sold comps. It is opinion only, no guaranteed grades, not an official PSA, BGS, CGC or CBCS grade, and prices change.
This is for people who already get these messages: Pokemon and TCG collectors with a good eye, sports card YouTubers who open a grading reveal every month, card shop regulars who know the comps, breakers, and small resellers who have sent enough submissions to know what comes back a 9. If people tag you under their pull and ask "sub or sell raw?", you already have the job. You just are not being paid for it yet.
What do collectors actually pay a card expert for?
They rarely need you to tell them what the card is. They know it is a Charizard, a Prizm rookie or a Moonbreon. What they want is a decision on one card, and they want it before they spend money on grading fees, shipping and insurance and then wait months for a slab.
The requests sound like this:
- "Front centering looks 55/45 but the back is rough. Is a PSA 10 realistic or am I paying to get a 9?"
- "There's a speck of whitening on the back top-left corner. Does that cap it?"
- "I pulled the special illustration rare. Grade it, or sell raw while it's still hot?"
- "I have 40 modern hits from this year. Which ten are worth the bulk tier?"
- "Should I crack my BGS 9.5 and resubmit to PSA?"
- "Japanese or English for this one, and PSA or CGC?"
- "My dad's 1989 Upper Deck binder is in the garage. Is anything in it worth grading?"
- "This listing says near mint. Do the photos agree before I buy it?"
Every one of these is a per-card decision driven by the same math: what the card sells for raw, what it sells for at the grade it will most likely get, how often that set gems, and how much the fee, shipping and wait eat out of the difference. That is the thing you know that most collectors don't, and it is worth paying for because a wrong guess costs them a grading fee on a card that comes back a 7.
Which checks should you sell first?
Start with one quick question and one or two photo checks. You can add more once you see which ones people order.
1. "Sub or sell?" as a Paid Question. The collector pays upfront to ask one private question and gets one written answer from you, with up to two follow-ups. There's no live call and nothing to schedule. You answer inside the reply window you choose, from 1 to 24 hours or 1 to 5 days. This works best for questions the collector can describe in words: the card name, set and number, language, what they paid, the centering they measured with a tool or app, the comps they found, and the grading tier they are considering. Good fits are "which company," "which tier," "crack and resub or keep," and "sell now or hold." More on how it works is on the Paid Questions page.
2. Grading candidate check, one card (Custom Work). You need to see the card for this one. The collector submits a brief and uploads photos before you start. You publish exactly what they get:
- a centering estimate for the front and back, left/right and top/bottom
- notes on corners, edges and surface, including whitening, print lines, holo scratches, dents and silvering
- a likely grade range, such as "PSA 8β9, outside shot at a 10"
- recent sold ranges for raw and for each grade in that range
- a verdict: grade it, sell raw or keep, plus which company and tier fits the card's value
A delivery time of one or two days is common for a single card.
3. Submission triage, one batch (Custom Work). This is for the collector with a stack of modern hits or a reseller building a submission. Set a clear scope, such as up to 25 cards per order. The collector uploads up to 5 files (for example, a photo of the fronts laid out in a grid, a photo of the backs, and close-ups of the cards they're unsure about) and lists the cards in the brief. You send back a ranked list as a spreadsheet: sub, sell raw or hold, with the reason in one line each. Three to five days is a realistic delivery time. Five days is the longest window you can set, so for a whole collection, sell one batch per order and let the collector order again for the next stack.
4. Value check from photos (Custom Work). This is for the old binder, the inherited box and the pre-purchase look at someone else's listing. You identify the set and the edition markers that matter (set symbol, 1st Edition stamp, shadowless border, rookie card designation, serial numbering, parallel), give a rough raw value range, and flag which cards deserve a closer grading check. Two or three days is a typical delivery time.
You write the scope, price, what you need from the buyer and the delivery time once, on the listing. Every order then arrives defined and paid. You don't have to agree on terms in DMs card by card. The Custom Work page shows how a listing is set up.
What photos should a collector send for a grading check?
How good your opinion is depends on the photos. Put a shot list in the "what I need from you" part of each Custom Work listing so collectors know what to send before they pay. A list that works for most cards:
- Straight-on front and back. Shoot the card out of the toploader so there's no glare. A penny sleeve is fine, or lay the card raw on a dark cloth. Fill the frame with all four edges visible.
- An angled shot under one light. Tilt the card toward a lamp so surface scratches, print lines, indents and roller marks show. Holo and foil cards need this most.
- Corner and edge close-ups. Ask for these on any card with dark borders or colored backs, where whitening and chipping show first. That includes vintage Pokemon backs and modern black-bordered sets.
- The details that change the value. Serial numbers, the autograph, the patch, the 1st Edition stamp, the language and the set number.
- A centering reading if they have one. A measurement from a centering tool or app saves you time and gives you something to check against.
Say plainly that a scanner flattens surface flaws and a phone shows them, so both help if they can manage it. Also say that blurry or glare-heavy photos will get a wider grade range in your note, not a guess dressed up as precision. Collectors respect that, and it keeps your opinions consistent.
What goes in a written grading opinion?
A good opinion follows the same structure every time, so the collector can compare it with the slab when it comes back. Here's an outline you can reuse:
- Card ID. Name, set, number, language, and parallel or edition.
- Centering. For example: "front roughly 57/43 left/right, 52/48 top/bottom; back 65/35."
- Corners, edges, surface. One line each, naming the exact spot: "light whitening back bottom-right, faint print line across the holo."
- Likely range. "Most likely a PSA 9. A 10 is possible but the back centering and that corner make it unlikely."
- The math. The recent sold range raw, at the likely grade and one grade above, set against what grading and shipping will cost them at the tier their declared value needs.
- Verdict. Grade, sell raw or hold, and which company and tier.
- Caveats. What photos can't show and what could move the result.
For Custom Work you deliver a written note plus up to 5 files, links, or both. Card experts tend to attach the photos marked up with centering lines and arrows on the flaws, a short spreadsheet for batches, and links to the sold listings the comps came from. Delivered files stay available to the collector for 90 days, so ask them to save anything they want to keep for their submission paperwork.
How should you price a card check?
You set the price. A useful anchor is what one bad submission costs the collector: a grading fee, shipping both ways and insurance on a card that comes back lower than they hoped. Your check should cost a clear fraction of that.
Common starting points:
- Paid Question ("sub or sell?"): often $10β$20, more if you answer within a few hours
- Single-card grading check from photos: often $15β$35, higher for vintage or high-value cards where one grade changes the price a lot
- Batch triage, up to 25 cards: often $50β$100
- Binder or listing value check: often $25β$60
Faster replies can cost more. A 6-hour window during a hot release week is worth more to a collector than a 3-day one. Keep the scope fixed in each listing. "Up to 25 cards" is a promise you can keep. "Look at my collection" is not. None of these prices is a promise of what you'll earn. Treat them as a starting point to adjust once you see what your followers order.
On cost: No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate. The full breakdown is on the pricing page.
What should you tell collectors before they pay?
Put one line at the top of every listing and repeat it in every note: Opinion only, no guaranteed grades; not an official PSA, BGS, CGC or CBCS grade; prices change.
Then explain why in plain words, because it makes your opinion more credible, not less:
- Photos hide things. Graders handle the card. They see surface dimples, factory wax stains, slight trimming and edge wear that a phone camera can miss.
- Grading isn't perfectly consistent. The same card can come back a grade apart on two submissions. Your range reflects that.
- Comps move. Modern Pokemon chase cards and hot rookies can swing a lot in a few weeks after a release, a tournament result or a playoff run. Date the comps in your note.
- Some cards should stop at you. If something looks trimmed, recolored or counterfeit, say so and tell the collector to have it examined in hand before spending anything on it. You're giving an opinion, not authenticating.
For Custom Work, you also write your own support, correction and refund policies, and collectors see them before they pay. Decide in advance what happens if photos turn out unusable or a card in the batch was missed. After delivery, the collector can contact you through a support conversation on the same order, and you handle it as the seller.
What if you pre-grade comic books instead of cards?
Comic grading advisors get the same "is it worth slabbing?" question, but the buyers, the flaws and the vocabulary are different enough to set up separately.
Who asks. Back-issue hunters, people who found a long box of 1990s books, collectors deciding whether to press and clean a book before submitting, and new buyers who aren't sure whether what they bought is a key issue.
What they ask. "Is this a key? Is it a first appearance, a first cover appearance or just a cameo?" "Newsstand or direct edition, and does it matter here?" "Is this a 9.4 or a 9.8 before I pay for CGC?" "Will pressing fix this spine roll, or is that a color-breaking crease?" "Which of these 300 books deserve slabs?"
What they should send. Front and back covers shot straight on, a spine close-up under raking light to show spine ticks and stress lines, the top and bottom edges, staples, one interior page so you can judge page quality (off-white versus white), and the indicia for printing and edition details.
What to sell:
- Pre-grade from photos before you pay for CGC or CBCS. A single-book Custom Work check covering spine ticks, corner blunting, Marvel chipping, creases (and whether they break color), staple rust, page quality, a likely grade range, and whether pressing first is likely to help.
- "Is this a key issue?" ID and value range. Often a Paid Question when the collector can give the title, issue number, cover date and variant. Make it Custom Work when you need to see the cover and indicia.
- Long box triage: which books are worth slabbing. Scope it to one batch per order, for example up to 25 books, since a full long box won't fit in one five-day window. Deliver a ranked list: slab, press then slab, sell raw, or keep as a reader copy.
Care wording for comics: Opinion only, not an official CGC or CBCS grade. Add that restoration, such as color touch or trimmed edges that would earn a restored label, can be invisible in photos, and that key-issue values move with film and series announcements.
Where do tips, videos and goals fit for a card channel?
Paid checks are the core, but the other offers fit naturally around a hobby channel:
- Tips. If you run free weekly price-check streams or post comps breakdowns, some viewers want to say thanks without asking anything. A tip is a one-time thank-you with nothing for you to deliver.
- Personalized Videos. Parents ask card YouTubers for a birthday message to a kid who collects Pokemon or follows a rookie class. The follower pays upfront, tells you who it's for and what to say, and you record it on your schedule at the price and delivery time you set.
- Goals. Name one goal, such as a better scanner and light box for sharper condition calls or the channel's next grading submission. Followers make one-time contributions, every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, there's no deadline unless you set one, and there's nothing to ship.
- Brand Collaboration Inquiries. Supply brands (sleeves, toploaders, binders, storage boxes) can use the Work with Me form, which collects budget, timeline and deliverables into a separate brand inbox, away from collector orders.
How do you start taking paid card checks this week?
- Create your page under the name collectors know. That can be your channel or shop name. Followers see the public name you choose on your page, at checkout and on their card statement. Your legal name goes only to payment verification and payouts.
- Add one Paid Question. Name it something like "Sub or sell raw?", pick a reply window you can keep in a busy week, and list what to include: card, set, number, language, centering reading, comps they found.
- Add one Custom Work listing. Start with the single-card grading check: the shot list, what your note covers, your delivery time, and the care line at the top.
- Put the link where the question shows up. Add it to your bio, and reply to "is this a 10?" comments with it instead of a free guess. Collectors pay by card as guests, without making an account.
- Start small. There's no follower minimum, so a low-traffic hobby blog or a channel with a few hundred subscribers can take its first order from the first reader who asks. Add batch triage once single checks are coming in.
Creators in 41 countries can get paid, and followers pay by card from anywhere. The how it works page walks through an order from start to finish. When your shot list and first listing are ready, create your Brillay page.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to be a PSA dealer or an official grader to sell grading opinions?
No. You're selling your own opinion based on experience, not a grade. State in every listing and every note that it's opinion only, with no guaranteed grades, and not an official PSA, BGS, CGC or CBCS grade. Collectors who order from you know that and want your eye before they spend money on grading.
What if the card comes back a grade lower than I estimated?
That will happen, because grading isn't perfectly consistent and photos hide flaws. Give ranges rather than single numbers, explain what pulled the range down, and write your correction and refund policy before you open orders so collectors see it before they pay. Most collectors care more about whether your reasoning held up than about one card landing a grade off.
Should a "should I grade this?" check be a Paid Question or Custom Work?
If the collector can describe the card and its numbers in words, a Paid Question is quick and cheap: one written answer plus up to two follow-ups. If you need to look at corners, edges and surface, use Custom Work, where they upload photos with the brief and you deliver a note with marked-up images.
Can I take a whole collection or a full long box in one order?
Scope each order so it fits inside your delivery window, which is five days at most. Sell a batch, such as up to 25 cards or books per order, and let the collector order again for the next batch. That keeps each delivery thorough and makes your price easy to understand.
How much does Brillay cost a card expert?
There's no monthly fee. A platform fee applies only when a collector actually pays you, and the exact rates are in the pricing section above. Card processing is separate.
Will buyers outside the US be able to pay me?
Yes. Followers pay by card from anywhere, and creators in 41 countries can receive payouts. That suits card collecting, where Japanese Pokemon buyers, European TCG players and US sports collectors often follow the same channels.
Explore more