Most “rate my cover” requests are really one of three questions: why does my voice crack on the high part, is this a belt or a shout, and what key should I sing this in. Vocal coaches get paid for those verdicts by putting a price on the take itself: the singer says which word cracks and what key they sang in, uploads the phone recording and pays before you press play. You send back notes pinned to the second the voice breaks, plus an audio warm-up set in their key. Shorter worries like “can I learn to mix at 40?” go in a separate written-answer offer.
This page is for voice teachers, singing teachers and vocal coaches who already get “rate my cover” comments. It also covers several narrower trades, each with its own section below: conservatory prescreen coaches, classical voice teachers, musical theatre audition coaches, harsh vocal coaches and trans voice coaches. If you mainly teach an instrument, where the student films their hands and the score, the music teachers page fits you better. Here the instrument is the singer's body, and that changes what you ask for, what you send back and what you must never promise.
What do singers actually send a vocal coach, and what are they asking?
Singers rarely ask for “a lesson.” They ask for a verdict on something they've already recorded. These are the requests you probably see every week:
- “Am I a soprano or a mezzo?” or “What's my voice type?” This usually comes from someone who has only ever sung along with the radio.
- “Why does my voice crack on the high part of the chorus?” That's the passaggio question in plain words.
- “Is this belting, or am I just yelling?”
- “What key should I sing this in?” Often this is a woman covering a male artist's song, or the reverse.
- “Rate my cover,” posted under your video with the duet still attached.
- A worship leader whose top notes are gone by the third song of a Sunday set, or a community-choir alto who keeps drifting onto the melody instead of her harmony line.
What arrives is almost always a phone recording. Some are unaccompanied. Others are sung over a backing track that's louder than the voice. Many of these singers play no instrument and don't read music. To them, “you're flat on the B-flat” means less than “at 0:42, on the word ‘free,’ you slide up into the note instead of landing on it.” That should shape everything you deliver: timestamps, plain words, and exercises they can hear rather than read.
Use the words singers search with in your listings: chest voice, head voice, mix, belt, falsetto, passaggio or “the break,” vocal fry, twang, vowel modification, breath support, range and tessitura.
Which offers should a vocal coach sell first?
Three offers cover most of what you get asked for. A fourth is optional.
1. Written feedback on one recording (Custom Work). This is your main offer. Scope it tightly, for example one song or up to two minutes of singing.
- What the singer sends: the recording (audio or video), the song title and the key they sang it in, their goal (“audition next month,” “I want to post this,” “my voice gets tired”) and anything they already know about their range.
- What you deliver: a written note with five to ten timestamped comments, the two or three things to fix first, and two or three exercises to practice.
- Delivery time: two or three days is a comfortable default. You can add a 24-hour version as a separate, higher-priced offer.
With Custom Work, you publish the price, scope and delivery time once. The singer then submits the brief and pays before you start.
2. A warm-up routine recorded in their range (Custom Work). Ask the singer for a slow siren from their lowest to their highest comfortable note, plus the song they're working on. You send back an audio file of you leading a 10–15 minute warm-up pitched for their voice. Typical exercises are lip trills, straw phonation, five-note scales on “nay” or “gee,” and sirens through the break. Add a short written page on what each exercise is for. Audio or video in a delivery can run up to 20 minutes, which is plenty for a warm-up. A delivery time of three to five days works well.
3. One technique question (Paid Questions). This is for questions where you don't need to hear anything. “Should I still warm up before choir if we do a group warm-up?” “Is it normal for belting to feel tiring?” “Can I learn to mix at 40?” The singer pays upfront and asks one private question, with up to two follow-ups. You answer in writing inside the reply time you set, and there's no call. Paid Questions are text only, so anything that needs a listen belongs in offer 1.
4. A Personalized Video (optional). Some examples: a two-minute pep talk the night before an audition, a “you've got this” for a choir member's first solo, or a birthday video for a student whose friends know your channel. The follower tells you who it's for and the occasion, and you record it on your schedule. See Personalized Videos.
How should a singer record the clip so you can actually judge it?
Put recording instructions in the “what I need” part of your listing. That saves you a back-and-forth on every order. A short version:
- Hold the phone three to four feet away at mouth height. Keep your face and shoulders in frame if the coach should see your jaw, neck and breathing.
- Turn off reverb, autotune and app filters. Only a dry take is an honest take.
- If you use a backing track, keep it quieter than your voice, or record a cappella.
- Write the song and the key in your brief.
- Send the take you're unsure about, not your most polished one.
Followers can attach up to 5 files to a Custom Work brief, each up to 50 MB. A phone audio file of one song fits easily. A long video may not, so ask singers to trim to the section that matters or paste a link to an unlisted video into the brief.
How do you write vocal feedback a singer can use without a piano?
Timestamped notes are the norm in this trade. Here is an example:
0:18, “I've been waiting”: the onset is breathy, so the phrase starts under pitch. Hum the line on “ng” first, then open into the words.
0:42, “free”: your larynx jumps up on the high note and the vowel spreads wide. Narrow it toward “freh” and keep the volume where it is.
1:05: great placement here. This is the sound to build from.
A few habits make notes like these usable:
- Lead with the strongest moment. It shows the singer what “right” feels like in their own voice.
- Cap the fixes at three. A singer who gets twenty corrections practices none of them.
- Name the note and the place. Write A4, and also say which word it falls on, so they don't need a keyboard to find it.
- Record exercises as audio. Most of your buyers can't read notation.
- Set exercises in their key, not yours. If you suggest transposing, say how many half steps up or down. That's the setting karaoke apps and backing-track sites use.
Where is the line on vocal health?
You'll get clips where the singer is clearly straining, and messages like “my throat hurts after practice, is that normal?” Put this line in every listing and in any reply that touches pain: Not medical advice; pain, hoarseness or voice loss should go to an ENT or voice therapist.
Then act on it. Don't prescribe “more support” to someone describing pain, and don't guess at nodules from a recording. Say plainly when something you hear is a reason to get checked before practicing more, such as breathiness that won't clear or a voice that has stayed husky for weeks. Your notes are technique coaching. Only a clinician can look at the vocal folds.
How do conservatory audition coaches sell prescreen feedback?
The buyer here is different. It's a high school senior, a parent, or a transfer student applying to voice programs, working against prescreen deadlines that pile up in late fall. Students ask you to review their Juilliard prescreen, and then the other four schools on their list, each with its own rules about languages, memorization, accompaniment and slating. Instrumental applicants come with the same problem and different repertoire.
What they send is the school's requirements, the prescreen recordings and their repertoire list. Two offers fit:
- Prescreen video feedback. You review one school's full prescreen set. You give notes on the singing or playing, and you check that each piece meets the stated requirements. You also look at the slate, framing and audio quality, and at whether the take is the strongest one to submit.
- Repertoire list review. The applicant sends their list, voice type or instrument, and target schools. You send back whether the list meets each school's rules, whether the language and period balance works, and which pieces show them at their best, with alternatives.
In November, shorten your delivery time or offer a rush version, because a review that arrives after the upload deadline is worthless. Put this in the listing: No guaranteed admission. You're improving a recording, not predicting a panel. For more on timing these offers, see selling audition and recital prep feedback.
What changes for classical voice teachers?
Your buyers are voice majors before juries and recitals, adult choral singers, and community opera chorus members. The questions are about legato, line, vowel purity, breath planning across a long phrase, recitative pacing and cadenza choices.
- Feedback on an aria recording. The singer sends the recording and the score edition they use. You send timestamped notes on line and technique, plus musical choices the panel will notice.
- Diction notes in Italian, German or French. The singer sends the text and a recording. You send an IPA transcription with the problem sounds marked, such as Italian double consonants, the German ich-laut and ach-laut, and French nasal vowels and mute e. Add an audio file of you speaking the text slowly.
Time these offers before jury weeks and recital dates. A fach question (“lyric or dramatic?”) needs a listen, so sell it as a short Custom Work review of one aria or art song, and say in your notes that one recording gives a starting point, not a verdict. General questions about repertoire for a fach you already know can be Paid Questions.
How do musical theatre audition coaches price a 16-bar cut review?
These buyers have a date: a community theatre casting call, a BFA audition or a self-tape due Friday. They don't want general voice lessons. They want to know whether this song, cut this way, shows them for this role.
- 16-bar cut review. The singer sends the sheet music PDF with the 16 or 32 bars marked, a recording and the role breakdown. You comment on song choice for their type (legit, belt, contemporary pop/rock), whether the cut shows range and a story, whether the accompanist can follow the markings, and how they're acting through the song.
- Self-tape feedback. The singer sends the tape and the sides. You cover singing, acting choices, eye line, slate, framing, light and sound.
Price the 24-hour version higher, because most of these orders arrive close to a deadline. For someone who has never done musical theatre and just saw a casting call, offer a starter version: you suggest two or three songs for their age and type and explain how to cut and mark one. A newly cast actor asking how to do a character study is a good Paid Question. If you're raising money for an original musical, to pay performers or record a demo, a Goal fits: followers chip in once, every contribution is yours whether or not the goal is reached, and there are no rewards to ship.
How do harsh vocal coaches sell feedback on scream clips?
Metal and hardcore singers learning fry screams, false chord, growls, highs and lows are often self-taught from videos. They send a short clip and ask “am I on track?” or “how do I add volume without it hurting?” Ask for the scream clip, a clean-voice line for comparison, and a sentence on how their throat feels afterward.
- Feedback on your fry scream clip. Cover air use, where the distortion seems to sit, and whether the volume is coming from resonance or from pushing.
- False chord exercise plan. Write one week of short daily steps with audio examples, delivered all at once.
Put this line in both listings: Technique coaching only; not medical advice for voice injury. When someone asks how to scream louder “without it hurting,” the honest answer starts with this: it shouldn't hurt. Pain means stop, not a technique gap to push through. Hoarseness that doesn't clear goes to an ENT.
What's different for trans voice coaches?
This is speaking voice, not singing. Trans and nonbinary adults working on voice feminization or masculinization send a reading passage (the Rainbow Passage is common), a phone-call style clip (“Hi, I'm calling to book an appointment”) or a stretch of casual conversation. They ask about pitch, resonance, intonation and being gendered correctly on the phone.
- Feedback on a voice recording with exercises. Give timestamped notes on resonance, pitch range and intonation, with audio demos of each exercise.
- 4-week feminization or masculinization practice plan. Write the whole four weeks up front and deliver it in one order. Each later check-in recording is a new order.
Wording matters more here than anywhere else on this page. Describe sound features against the goal they named (“resonance is darker than your target on this phrase”) rather than judging whether they “pass.” Let them choose how much they share. The order thread is private, and the follower pays as a guest without making an account. Put this in your listing: voice training only, not speech therapy or medical advice. Send anyone with voice pain or post-surgery questions to a speech-language pathologist.
How much should a vocal coach charge for recording feedback?
You set the price. Price by the time an order really takes: listening three or four times, writing the notes and recording the exercises. Common starting points:
- A Paid Question: $15–35.
- Written feedback on one recording: $40–90.
- A warm-up routine recorded in their range: $45–75.
- A prescreen set review or a 24-hour 16-bar cut review: $75–150.
- A Personalized Video: $20–50.
Raise prices when your queue fills or deadlines bunch up. Keep your weekly private lessons, holiday policies and lesson packages running the way they do now. These offers cover the one-off listens that come in between, from singers who would never book a recurring slot.
No monthly fee, you only pay a small platform fee when you get paid. 8% platform fee when a follower pays for work, 5% platform fee on tips and goals. Card processing is separate.
Coaches in 41 countries can get paid, and singers pay by card from anywhere. Followers see the public name you choose, not your legal name. Details are on the pricing page.
How do you get started this week?
- Create your page and publish two offers: recording feedback as Custom Work and a technique question as Paid Questions.
- In the recording-feedback listing, write what you need (the clip, song, key, goal and range), what you deliver (timestamped notes plus two or three exercises), what's excluded (live lessons, medical questions) and your delivery time.
- Write your support, correction and refund policies. Singers see them before paying, which answers the “what if I'm not happy?” question up front.
- Add the vocal-health line to every listing.
- Put your link in your bio. The next time someone comments “rate my cover,” reply with the link instead of a free verdict.
You can create your free Brillay page and have the first offer live today.
Frequently asked questions
Can singers send me video, or only audio?
Both, through Custom Work: up to 5 files with the brief, each up to 50 MB, or a link to an unlisted video pasted into the brief. Paid Questions are text only, so use them for questions that don't need a listen.
What if a singer fixes the problem and wants me to listen again?
Each new take is a new order. There are no built-in revision rounds. After you deliver a Custom Work order, the singer can message you on that order if a file won't play or a note is unclear. How you handle corrections is up to the policy you publish.
Can I sell an eight-week vocal program?
Not as one order, because the longest delivery time is five days. Sell a clearly scoped piece instead, like one week's plan or a written four-week plan delivered at once. Price each check-in recording as its own order.
What does Brillay cost a vocal coach?
There's no monthly fee, and a platform fee applies only when a singer actually pays you. The exact rates are in the pricing section above.
Do singers need an account to pay?
No. They pay by card as a guest, straight from your link.
What about refunds when a singer changes their mind?
Nothing is booked, so there's no lesson to cancel. You write your refund policy, and singers see it before paying and on their order page.
Explore more